Controversy over Yelp Reviews Reinforces the Need for Honest Vacation Home Reviews

Last week, East Bay Express,  a San Francisco based publication, published a story accusing Yelp – a popular local business review site – of altering review content in exchange for monthly advertising fees.   The article included testimonials of local businesses that claimed they were offered a Yelp advertising program to improve their reviews on Yelp for a fee.

I will refrain on commenting on the merits of the accusations, but instead use the topic of the story to highlight the value of trusted review content.


The Value of a Review is a Function of its Honesty

The internet has enabled the consumer masses to participate in the product and service marketing process.  We consumers are no longer limited to one-way marketing pitches and information to make our decisions.  Company X may claim they sell the best widget on the market, which may be the case, but unless we can see some verified testimonials and reviews from past widget users it’s just a marketing pitch.

The challenge becomes making sure the testimonials and reviews we leverage when making our decision are from real ‘unfiltered’ consumers.    This is why the Yelp article mentioned above received so much attention last week.   Yelp attracts over 20M people per month that rely on the site to find and select the best local restaurants, hair salons, etc..   If consumers began to question the honesty of the reviews they find on Yelp, then the value of the site, service and reviews are diminished.

FlipKey’s Commitment to Honest Vacation Homes Reviews

At FlipKey maintaining the trust, verification and honesty of our reviews is paramount to helping ensure travelers find and book the best vacation rentals that meet their needs.  As such, we take great efforts to ensure our reviews are honest and authentic:

 - FlipKey clients can not pay to move, adjust or prioritize reviews

-  FlipKey only solicits reviews through a closed email invitation process that ensures only confirmed guests are able to leave a review.  FlipKey’s system curbs the instances of competitors leaving false negatives on homes they have never stayed in.

-  The only reviews removed from FlipKey are reviews that violate FlipKey terms of service (e.g. contain profanity, personal attacks, etc.)

-  All FlipKey reviews are applied to FlipKey’s ‘authentication filter’ that identifies false positives (managers reviewing their own homes) and SPAM

-   FlipKey publishes all reviews in chronological order, no matter if the review is a glowing 5-star review or a critical 2-star review.

Therefore, when you see a review is “Verified by FlipKey” trust that the content is honest and complete.



  1. YES, I agree. Reviews should never be altered. Its a numbers thing...if you get enough reviews, the bad ones will work their way out. A guest was towed at our vacation rental and he was pretty upset. I ended paying the towing but he still wrote a bad review on but we've had enough good ones to not make it as relevant. Shame on Yelp.

  2. Hi,just identified your web-site when i google something and wonder what web hosting do you use for your wordpress,the speed is more faster than my website, i really want to know it.will back to check it out,i appreciate it!

  3. I am simply trying to find a place to review a palm springs rental called "Sun Villa San Lorenzo," in palm springs from We feel that if we had real reviews about the property, we would not have paid the $600 per night rental and stayed somewhere else. The house was okay, not the way it is hyped, the kitchen is old 1970's style and small. The backyard is great. and the home fairly nice, but you need to go through some bedrooms to get to others, making some not really that private.

    The worst part about the place was the thermostat permanently set at 84'. This was completely uncomfortable and we were told that nothing could be done about it. Nobody could sleep, outside was even hotter, even at night. The kitchen would get to 90-95' when cooking. Combine this with the fact that they had a mandatory cleaning fee, and then charged $200 for extra cleaning because the fridge was not cleaned out, made us really peeved. This was a year ago and it still makes me mad. That is why I am trying to find a way for people to know that this rental company does not care about their customers. We ended up paying over $700 per night for a place that was worth $200 if it had the proper air conditioning.

    Help me find a place to warn others. I have never left a bad review before. Somebody help me find a place to publish a review! Thank you.

  4. When furnishing a rental property in Central Florida (Orlando, Kissimmee, Davenport, Celebration, Reunion), here are some things you should consider:

    Tenants usually expect the home to be not only completely functional, but attractive and stylish. By using a professional decorator, your home will be stylish and up-to-date with furnishings and décor. Using pleasing colors and coordinating design throughout is sure to make your short-term rental home inviting, comfortable, and a cut above the rest. Of course using a decorator can be costly; however, using a company that employs professional decorators as part of their staff (such as ) will avoid the additional expense and achieve the professional look without additional expense.

    Buy furniture that is of good quality, yet affordable. Comfortable seating in the living area(s) creates a relaxed atmosphere which invites a return stay from your guests.

    One of the most important things to remember is the comfort of your guest. Using quality durable mattresses is a must. An orthopedic medium-firm mattress has shown to be a good compromise between guests whose preferences lean towards either a softer or harder mattress.

    Making your vacation home kid-friendly is a good idea. Many owners choose to add designs specifically geared towards children adding character room designs such as Disney’s Mickey Mouse, Minnie Mouse, and other characters. Game systems such as Playstation, Nintendo, and others are certain to keep the kids occupied while the parents relax. Remember, it’s all about your guests!

    It is important to buy from a reputable company who is recommended by others and is able to provide you with such references.

Leave a Reply