John and I fully restored our cottage so it is a wonderful "magical" place to visit, unwind and just enjoy. We hope our visitors experience the unique nature of the North Fork with its beautiful beaches, enticing wineries and delectable restaurants.
Reviewed by Real Travelers
John Andrew's Cottage is a "turnkey" experience accommodating two adults and children including: -a cozy bedroom with its full size bed, which beckons you after a sun-filled day at the private beach (within walking distance) which overlooks Shelter Island -a complete kitchen and full bath -a livingroom filled with antique…
2 guest reviews
100% of guests would stay again
Left on Aug 22, 2014 for a stay in August 2014
my daughter (5 1/2 year old) and i had a great visit here. the cottage was cute and comfortable. having the backyard was great too. the hosts were very friendly and accommodating, and even sent us off with cherry tomatoes, herbs and a bottle of bubbles when we were leaving. i would definitely recommend staying here to a couple or small family. we hope to come back someday!
beth b, Brooklyn, New York