New Carlisle Rentals

Close

Enter dates for more accurate prices

Payment Protection
Your payment for this rental is protected when you pay through FlipKey. Learn more

136 Houses

(2) Excellent 

    12

    Cozy home in the country just steps away from the lake

    Indiana / New Carlisle

    New Carlisle house

    2 7 1 night min

    • 2 bedrooms
    • sleeps 7
    • 1 night min
    • Child Friendly
    • Air conditioning

    Price per night from

    $229

    Price per night from

    $229

    (16) Excellent 

    Certificate of Excellence

      15

      Lakefront cottage on scenic Hudson Lake

      Indiana / New Carlisle

      New Carlisle cottage

      2 4 2 nights min

      • 2 bedrooms
      • sleeps 4
      • 2 nights min
      • Beach / lakeside relaxation
      • Nearest beach 25 mi
      • Air conditioning

      Certificate of Excellence

      Price per night from

      $172

      Price per night from

      $172

      Great rentals within 20 miles that match your search

      Distance approx 19.4 km from New Carlisle

      (4) Excellent 

        28

        4BR 3BA Short Walk to Beach - New Furnishings 8/15

        Indiana / Michigan City

        Michigan City house

        4 14 2 nights min

        • 4 bedrooms
        • sleeps 14
        • 2 nights min
        • Beach / lakeside relaxation
        • Child Friendly
        • Air conditioning

        Price per night from

        $629

        Price per night from

        $629

        Distance approx 12.65 km from New Carlisle

        (6) Very Good 

          20

          Beautifully renovated 2 bedroom duplex

          Berrien County / Union Pier

          Union Pier cottage

          2 4 3 nights min

          • 2 bedrooms
          • sleeps 4
          • 3 nights min
          • Beach / lakeside relaxation
          • Child Friendly
          • Air conditioning

          Price per night from

          $258

          Responds fast!
          avg. 1 hour 5 minutes

          Price per night from

          $258

          Distance approx 18.95 km from New Carlisle

          (3) Excellent 

            24

            View of the lake from 2 decks - Lakeshore Dr 6br!

            Indiana / Michigan City

            Michigan City house

            6 15 2 nights min

            • 6 bedrooms
            • sleeps 15
            • 2 nights min
            • Beach / lakeside relaxation
            • Child Friendly
            • Air conditioning

            Price per night from

            $914

            Price per night from

            $914

            Distance approx 19.82 km from New Carlisle

            (1) Very Good 

              18

              Il Giardino

              Indiana / Michigan City

              Michigan City house

              3 8 3 nights min

              • 3 bedrooms
              • sleeps 8
              • 3 nights min
              • Nearest beach 5 mi
              • Child Friendly
              • Air conditioning

              Price per night from

              $262

              Price per night from

              $262

              Distance approx 15.53 km from New Carlisle

              (15) Excellent 

                23

                Beautifully Renovated 'Pinebrook Cottage' 2BR 1BA

                Berrien County / New Buffalo

                New Buffalo house

                2 6 2 nights min

                • 2 bedrooms
                • sleeps 6
                • 2 nights min
                • Child Friendly
                • Air conditioning
                • Private garden

                Price per night from

                $298

                Responds fast!
                avg. 34 minutes

                Price per night from

                $298

                Distance approx 14.91 km from New Carlisle

                  27

                  Hot Tub, Theater Room, 15 Min Walk ND, Sleep 18+

                  Indiana / South Bend

                  South Bend house

                  4 20 2 nights min

                  • 4 bedrooms
                  • sleeps 20
                  • 2 nights min
                  • Child Friendly
                  • Car not necessary

                  Price per night from

                  $287

                  Price per night from

                  $287

                  Distance approx 12.64 km from New Carlisle

                    24

                    Inviting Union Pier Home w/ Hot Tub-Walk to Beach!

                    Berrien County / Union Pier

                    Union Pier house

                    5 10 min stay varies

                    • 5 bedrooms
                    • sleeps 10
                    • min stay varies
                    • Child Friendly

                    Price per night from

                    $481

                    Responds fast!
                    avg. 7 minutes

                    Price per night from

                    $481

                    Distance approx 19.01 km from New Carlisle

                    (5) Very Good 

                      9

                      Mint Julep

                      Indiana / Michigan City

                      Michigan City house

                      2 6 min stay varies

                      • 2 bedrooms
                      • sleeps 6
                      • min stay varies
                      • Beach / lakeside relaxation
                      • Swimming pool
                      • Child Friendly

                      Price per night from

                      $172

                      Price per night from

                      $172

                      Distance approx 14.86 km from New Carlisle

                        17

                        Charming 3 bedroom home - 2 miles from Notre Dame's campus!

                        Indiana / South Bend

                        South Bend house

                        3 7 2 nights min

                        • 3 bedrooms
                        • sleeps 7
                        • 2 nights min
                        • Child Friendly
                        • Air conditioning
                        • Pet Friendly

                        Price per night from

                        $687

                        Price per night from

                        $687

                        Distance approx 14.19 km from New Carlisle

                        (4) Excellent 

                          21

                          Charming, Updated Sawyer Dune Cottage--Next to Warren Dunes + Private Beach!

                          Berrien County / Sawyer

                          Sawyer cottage

                          3 8 3 nights min

                          • 3 bedrooms
                          • sleeps 8
                          • 3 nights min
                          • Child Friendly
                          • Air conditioning
                          • Private garden

                          Price per night from

                          $315

                          Price per night from

                          $315

                          Distance approx 7.97 km from New Carlisle

                            24

                            2BR Three Oaks House w/Extensive Yard!

                            Berrien County / Three Oaks

                            Three Oaks house

                            2 6 min stay varies

                            • 2 bedrooms
                            • sleeps 6
                            • min stay varies
                            • Child Friendly
                            • Air conditioning

                            Price per night from

                            $125

                            Responds fast!
                            avg. 7 minutes

                            Price per night from

                            $125

                            Distance approx 13.22 km from New Carlisle

                              27

                              'The Peachtree Cottage'-5 Min to New Buffalo Beach

                              Berrien County / New Buffalo

                              New Buffalo cottage

                              3 8 min stay varies

                              • 3 bedrooms
                              • sleeps 8
                              • min stay varies
                              • Ski
                              • Child Friendly
                              • Air conditioning

                              Price per night from

                              $182

                              Responds fast!
                              avg. 7 minutes

                              Price per night from

                              $182

                              Distance approx 14.73 km from New Carlisle

                                25

                                Luxury Riverfront Estate

                                Berrien County / Niles

                                Niles house

                                2 8 1 night min

                                • 2 bedrooms
                                • sleeps 8
                                • 1 night min
                                • Child Friendly
                                • Air conditioning
                                • Private garden

                                Price per night from

                                $1,060

                                Price per night from

                                $1,060

                                Distance approx 12.77 km from New Carlisle

                                (21) Very Good 

                                  21

                                  2 FUN 4 Bedroom 2 Bath COTTAGES each Sleep 10 people Beach-Pool-Hot Tub and More

                                  Berrien County / Lakeside

                                  Lakeside cottage

                                  8 20 min stay varies

                                  • 8 bedrooms
                                  • sleeps 20
                                  • min stay varies
                                  • Nearest beach 0.05 mi
                                  • Swimming pool
                                  • Child Friendly

                                  Price per night from

                                  $447

                                  Responds fast!
                                  avg. 39 minutes

                                  Price per night from

                                  $447

                                  Distance approx 19.14 km from New Carlisle

                                  (21) Excellent 

                                    36

                                    Moondance--Huge Open Concept in Central Beachwalk

                                    Indiana / Michigan City

                                    Michigan City house

                                    6 16 min stay varies

                                    • 6 bedrooms
                                    • sleeps 16
                                    • min stay varies
                                    • Beach / lakeside relaxation
                                    • Nearest beach 0.02 mi
                                    • Swimming pool
                                    “Great location with great amenities” Loved the house. Great floor plan for large families and extended family. Loved the boardwalk to the beach and the trail around the lake. The kids liked the basketball court and the play area. The office was he

                                    Price per night from

                                    $350

                                    Responds fast!
                                    avg. 46 minutes

                                    Price per night from

                                    $350

                                    Distance approx 8.36 km from New Carlisle

                                      26

                                      Sycamore Guesthouse

                                      Berrien County / Three Oaks

                                      Three Oaks house

                                      5 13 min stay varies

                                      • 5 bedrooms
                                      • sleeps 13
                                      • min stay varies
                                      • Child Friendly
                                      • Air conditioning
                                      • Private garden

                                      Price per night from

                                      $630

                                      Responds fast!
                                      avg. 2 hours 0 minutes

                                      Price per night from

                                      $630

                                      Distance approx 16.91 km from New Carlisle

                                        6

                                        Dune Farmhouse

                                        Indiana / Long Beach

                                        Long Beach house

                                        2 4 2 nights min

                                        • 2 bedrooms
                                        • sleeps 4
                                        • 2 nights min
                                        • Child Friendly
                                        • Air conditioning

                                        Price per night from

                                        $287

                                        Price per night from

                                        $287

                                        Distance approx 15.37 km from New Carlisle

                                        (3) Excellent 

                                          33

                                          June Weekly Discounts. 5* rated. Block to Lake MI. Golf Cart (seasonal). Private

                                          Berrien County / New Buffalo

                                          New Buffalo house

                                          3 9 min stay varies

                                          • 3 bedrooms
                                          • sleeps 9
                                          • min stay varies
                                          • Beach / lakeside relaxation
                                          • Child Friendly
                                          • Air conditioning

                                          Price per night from

                                          $229

                                          Responds fast!
                                          avg. 38 minutes

                                          Price per night from

                                          $229

                                          Distance approx 13.32 km from New Carlisle

                                            15

                                            Barton Street Bungalow

                                            Berrien County / New Buffalo

                                            New Buffalo house

                                            4 8 min stay varies

                                            • 4 bedrooms
                                            • sleeps 8
                                            • min stay varies
                                            • Child Friendly
                                            • Air conditioning
                                            • Private garden

                                            Price per night from

                                            $287

                                            Price per night from

                                            $287

                                            Distance approx 12.8 km from New Carlisle

                                              14

                                              Charming Michigan Cottage

                                              Berrien County / Union Pier

                                              Union Pier cottage

                                              2 4 2 nights min

                                              • 2 bedrooms
                                              • sleeps 4
                                              • 2 nights min
                                              • Nearest beach 0.5 mi
                                              • Child Friendly
                                              • Air conditioning

                                              Price per night from

                                              $308

                                              Price per night from

                                              $308

                                              Distance approx 12.95 km from New Carlisle

                                                27

                                                Cozy Sawyer Studio Cabin - Walk to Harbert Beach!

                                                Berrien County / Sawyer

                                                Sawyer log cabin

                                                2 5 2 nights min

                                                • 2 bedrooms
                                                • sleeps 5
                                                • 2 nights min
                                                • Ski
                                                • Child Friendly
                                                • Air conditioning

                                                Price per night from

                                                $172

                                                Responds fast!
                                                avg. 19 minutes

                                                Price per night from

                                                $172

                                                Distance approx 8.08 km from New Carlisle

                                                  25

                                                  Three Oaks Inn at Ashmoor Estate

                                                  Berrien County / Three Oaks

                                                  Three Oaks b and b

                                                  5 14 2 nights min

                                                  • 5 bedrooms
                                                  • sleeps 14
                                                  • 2 nights min
                                                  • Child Friendly
                                                  • Air conditioning
                                                  • Private garden

                                                  Price per night from

                                                  $773

                                                  Responds fast!
                                                  avg. 2 hours 2 minutes

                                                  Price per night from

                                                  $773

                                                  Distance approx 18.32 km from New Carlisle

                                                  (8) Excellent 

                                                    33

                                                    Glint on the Water

                                                    Berrien County / Berrien Springs

                                                    Berrien Springs house

                                                    4 14 3 nights min

                                                    • 4 bedrooms
                                                    • sleeps 14
                                                    • 3 nights min
                                                    • Beach / lakeside relaxation
                                                    • Nearest beach 40 mi
                                                    • Child Friendly

                                                    Price per night from

                                                    $401

                                                    Responds fast!
                                                    avg. 1 hour 20 minutes

                                                    Price per night from

                                                    $401

                                                    Distance approx 12.57 km from New Carlisle

                                                      22

                                                      Your Pool Party is Calling

                                                      Berrien County / Lakeside

                                                      Lakeside house

                                                      3 10 7 nights min

                                                      • 3 bedrooms
                                                      • sleeps 10
                                                      • 7 nights min
                                                      • Swimming pool
                                                      • Child Friendly
                                                      • Air conditioning

                                                      Price per night from

                                                      $458

                                                      Price per night from

                                                      $458

                                                      Distance approx 9.35 km from New Carlisle

                                                      (7) Excellent 

                                                        33

                                                        The Farmhouse Stay, LLC

                                                        Indiana / South Bend

                                                        South Bend house

                                                        4 6 2 nights min

                                                        • 4 bedrooms
                                                        • sleeps 6
                                                        • 2 nights min
                                                        • Nearest beach 43 mi
                                                        • Child Friendly
                                                        • Air conditioning

                                                        Price per night from

                                                        $144

                                                        Price per night from

                                                        $144

                                                        Distance approx 16.55 km from New Carlisle

                                                        (1) Excellent 

                                                          48

                                                          Lake Michigan's Silver Suite, SWM Bike Trail

                                                          Berrien County / Bridgman

                                                          Bridgman house

                                                          2 6 min stay varies

                                                          • 2 bedrooms
                                                          • sleeps 6
                                                          • min stay varies
                                                          • Nearest beach 1 mi
                                                          • Child Friendly
                                                          • Car not necessary

                                                          Price per night from

                                                          $196

                                                          Responds fast!
                                                          avg. 7 minutes

                                                          Price per night from

                                                          $196

                                                          Distance approx 16.55 km from New Carlisle

                                                          (1) Excellent 

                                                            34

                                                            Lake Michigan's Lakeside Suite. Wine, Dine, & Brew

                                                            Berrien County / Bridgman

                                                            Bridgman condo

                                                            2 4 min stay varies

                                                            • 2 bedrooms
                                                            • sleeps 4
                                                            • min stay varies
                                                            • Child Friendly
                                                            • Car not necessary
                                                            • Air conditioning

                                                            Price per night from

                                                            $196

                                                            Responds fast!
                                                            avg. 7 minutes

                                                            Price per night from

                                                            $196

                                                            Distance approx 13.21 km from New Carlisle

                                                              31

                                                              Walk to Notre Dame from Historic Riverside home 4 BR sleeps 12!

                                                              Indiana / South Bend

                                                              South Bend house

                                                              4 12 2 nights min

                                                              • 4 bedrooms
                                                              • sleeps 12
                                                              • 2 nights min
                                                              • Child Friendly
                                                              • Air conditioning
                                                              • Pet Friendly

                                                              Price per night from

                                                              $172

                                                              Price per night from

                                                              $172

                                                              Distance approx 12.84 km from New Carlisle

                                                              (2) Excellent 

                                                                18

                                                                Keller Park House - 2.1 miles from Notre Dame

                                                                Indiana / South Bend

                                                                South Bend house

                                                                4 9 2 nights min

                                                                • 4 bedrooms
                                                                • sleeps 9
                                                                • 2 nights min
                                                                • Air conditioning

                                                                Price per night from

                                                                $640

                                                                Price per night from

                                                                $640

                                                                Distance approx 14.86 km from New Carlisle

                                                                (3) Excellent 

                                                                  24

                                                                  Everything Is New From Beds To Kitchen Cabinets

                                                                  Berrien County / New Buffalo

                                                                  New Buffalo cottage

                                                                  2 6 2 nights min

                                                                  • 2 bedrooms
                                                                  • sleeps 6
                                                                  • 2 nights min
                                                                  • Child Friendly
                                                                  • Air conditioning
                                                                  • Pet Friendly

                                                                  Price per night from

                                                                  $258

                                                                  Responds fast!
                                                                  avg. 3 hours 33 minutes

                                                                  Price per night from

                                                                  $258

                                                                  Distance approx 13.21 km from New Carlisle

                                                                    29

                                                                    Villa Wine

                                                                    Berrien County / New Buffalo

                                                                    New Buffalo house

                                                                    5 16 min stay varies

                                                                    • 5 bedrooms
                                                                    • sleeps 16
                                                                    • min stay varies
                                                                    • Child Friendly
                                                                    • Pet Friendly

                                                                    Price per night from

                                                                    $286

                                                                    Price per night from

                                                                    $286

                                                                    Distance approx 19.12 km from New Carlisle

                                                                      19

                                                                      Historic Home for Notre Dame Weekends, 5 miles from campus

                                                                      Indiana / Granger

                                                                      Granger chateau

                                                                      4 10 3 nights min

                                                                      • 4 bedrooms
                                                                      • sleeps 10
                                                                      • 3 nights min
                                                                      • Child Friendly
                                                                      • Air conditioning
                                                                      • Private garden

                                                                      Price per night from

                                                                      $344

                                                                      Price per night from

                                                                      $344

                                                                      Distance approx 12.78 km from New Carlisle

                                                                      (4) Excellent 

                                                                        75

                                                                        Shorewinds Beach House on LakeShore

                                                                        Berrien County / Union Pier

                                                                        Union Pier house

                                                                        2 5 min stay varies

                                                                        • 2 bedrooms
                                                                        • sleeps 5
                                                                        • min stay varies
                                                                        • Child Friendly
                                                                        • Air conditioning
                                                                        • Private garden

                                                                        Price per night from

                                                                        $201

                                                                        Price per night from

                                                                        $201

                                                                        Distance approx 16.55 km from New Carlisle

                                                                        (1) Excellent 

                                                                          45

                                                                          Sunset Condo at The Monogram Inn & Suites

                                                                          Berrien County / Bridgman

                                                                          Bridgman condo

                                                                          2 8 2 nights min

                                                                          • 2 bedrooms
                                                                          • sleeps 8
                                                                          • 2 nights min
                                                                          • Child Friendly
                                                                          • Air conditioning

                                                                          Price per night from

                                                                          $516

                                                                          Responds fast!
                                                                          avg. 7 minutes

                                                                          Price per night from

                                                                          $516

                                                                          Distance approx 19.65 km from New Carlisle

                                                                          (11) Very Good 

                                                                            41

                                                                            On the beach with rooftop Great VIEWS!! Lake Michigan in your Back yard

                                                                            Indiana / Michigan City

                                                                            Michigan City townhouse

                                                                            3 16 min stay varies

                                                                            • 3 bedrooms
                                                                            • sleeps 16
                                                                            • min stay varies
                                                                            • Child Friendly
                                                                            • Air conditioning
                                                                            • Private garden

                                                                            Price per night from

                                                                            $373

                                                                            Price per night from

                                                                            $373

                                                                            Distance approx 11.71 km from New Carlisle

                                                                              33

                                                                              Fun Central for ND Events/SW Mich Attractions

                                                                              Berrien County / Niles

                                                                              Niles house

                                                                              3 10 2 nights min

                                                                              • 3 bedrooms
                                                                              • sleeps 10
                                                                              • 2 nights min
                                                                              • Nearest beach 37 mi
                                                                              • Swimming pool
                                                                              • Child Friendly

                                                                              Price per night from

                                                                              $916

                                                                              Price per night from

                                                                              $916