Starkey Rentals

Close

Updating...

Enter dates for more accurate prices

79 Houses

Private Keuka Lake-front Chalet | Stunning Views & Game Room Sleeps 10

Dundee house

3 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms / sleeps 10

Price per night from

$453

Price per night from

$372

Lawson's Place

Dundee house

5 bedrooms / 3 bathrooms / sleeps 10

“Family 4th in wine country” Great location to all things to see and do. Had a great view of the lake from every front window. Very spacious but could use some more cooking and serving items with bigger coffee cups. Had a little hiccup with the water for the house but the owner was right on it and fixed the problem right away a very nice gentleman.

Price per night from

$361

The Farmhouse at Fulkerson Winery

Dundee house

4 bedrooms / 3 bathrooms / sleeps 10

Price per night from

$687

Tentrr - Beerocracy Colonial Camp

Rock Stream tented camp

1 bedroom / 1 bathroom / sleeps 4

Price per night from

$165

Tentrr - Beerocracy Commonwealth Camp

Rock Stream tented camp

1 bedroom / 1 bathroom / sleeps 4

Price per night from

$165

Great rentals within 20 miles that match your search

Cozy Boat on the Watkins Glen Waterfront! ⚓️

Watkins Glen yacht

1 bedroom / 1 bathroom / sleeps 3

Price per night from

$171

Secluded All-Season Home with Outdoor Cedar Hot Tub, close to Wineries and Lake

Watkins Glen house

3 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms / sleeps 8

Price per night from

$372

Hunter's View Retreat on 30 Acres

Bradford log cabin

2 bedrooms / 1 bathroom / sleeps 7

“Excellent Hunting Getaway” Spent a great mens week hunting the local state land. Everyone saw deer but were unable to connect. The cabin had all the amenities for a semi rustic experience. The host John was very helpful with local information in regard to hunting areas and activities for all seasons.

Responds fast! avg. 1 hour 50 minutes

Price per night from

$125

Seneca Lake Escape-Stunning Post & Beam

Romulus house

3 bedrooms / 3 bathrooms / sleeps 8

Responds fast! avg. 48 minutes

Price per night from

$658

3 bedroom Seneca Lake East Side

Lodi cottage

3 bedrooms / 1 bathroom / sleeps 6

“Wonderful spot in the heart of the Wine Trail!” We had a wonderful time at Ann's place. The trailer was comfortable and stayed cool in the summer heat. Ann and Carl were perfect hosts, even treating us to a bonfire one night! We would highly recommend this spot.

Price per night from

$286

Secluded cabin with amenities near Keuka and Seneca Lake

Hammondsport cottage

3 bedrooms / 1 bathroom / sleeps 10

Price per night from

$286

Naples House w/Hot Tub & Deck - Near Finger Lakes!

Middlesex house

2 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms / sleeps 6

Responds fast! avg. 1 hour 6 minutes

Price per night from

$258

MALLARD COTTAGE, DESIGNED JUST FOR THE TWO OF YOU AND.....YOUR PET!

Ithaca cottage

1 bedroom / 1 bathroom / sleeps 3

Responds fast! avg. 33 minutes

Price per night from

$286

Locke's Glen on the Lake - Lower Level

Geneva apartment

2 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms / sleeps 8

Price per night from

$378

Pebble Beach

Romulus cottage

3 bedrooms / 1 bathroom / sleeps 10

“A beautiful cottage with lasting memories” Love everything about this cottage, inside and out! The sunsets are amazing! Perfect location for relaxing and/or touring the wineries.

Responds fast! avg. 3 hours 18 minutes

Price per night from

$401

Brookside Cottage in quaint village 10 minutes from wine trail

Interlaken house

2 bedrooms / 1 bathroom / sleeps 8

“Cute, clean, roomy, modern and nice location” We wanted to spend the weekend right in the middle of wine country and all the different parks in the area. This place fit the bill. Nicely decorated, warm, quiet and very clean and right in the middle of what we wanted. Several great places to eat about 7 miles down the road in Trumansburg.

Responds fast! avg. 1 hour 7 minutes

Price per night from

$171

Gracious, Spacious Guest House in Village

Aurora house

5 bedrooms / 3 bathrooms / sleeps 11

Price per night from

$1,087

Owl Moon Cottage - A Romantic Finger Lakes Getaway, Family Friendly Too!

Newfield cottage

1 bedroom / 1 bathroom / sleeps 4

“Beautiful Place” The cabin/house was absolutely beautiful. Tons of natural light, huge deck, private, great scenery all around. Everything was clean and new. The location is excellent, just minutes to all kind of waterfalls and short hikes, and also minutes from Ithaca and a million places to eat. By far the best place we've booked with flipkey so far.

Responds fast! avg. 38 minutes

Price per night from

$172

Executive four bedroom rental year round private home with all amenities!

Romulus house

4 bedrooms / 3 bathrooms / sleeps 8

“Great family vacation!” My family had a wonderful vacation here! So much to do, so little time! We kayaked, went fishing off the dock, swam in the lake & relaxed in the hot tub. We went to Watkins Glen & Robert Treman State Parks. And also visited some local wineries/breweries/distilleries. The views in the home were amazing! So beautiful to wake up to each morning! And it was so great to have the amenities provided by the owner, who made herself available for any questions. We definitely made some memories that will last a lifetime!

Responds fast! avg. 1 hour 33 minutes

Price per night from

$409

Responds fast! avg. 1 hour 7 minutes

Price per night from

$274

Burdett House B&B - Knickerbocker Room

Burdett b&b

1 bedroom / 1 bathroom / sleeps 2

Price per night from

$189

Responds fast! avg. 1 hour 7 minutes

Price per night from

$274

Burdett House B&B - Empire Room

Burdett b&b

1 bedroom / 1 bathroom / sleeps 2

Price per night from

$189

Luxury Sheldrake Farm House on Cayuga Lake Wine Trail, Finger Lakes

Ovid house

4 bedrooms / 3 bathrooms / sleeps 8

Price per night from

$630

Beautiful Seneca Lake - Lakefront Cottage

Geneva cottage

2 bedrooms / 1 bathroom / sleeps 6

“Wonderful Thanksgiving at Lakefront Seneca Cottage” We came for a romantic Thanksgiving getaway and everything at the cottage was comfortable, clean, and conducive to relaxing! It was super cold (18 degrees), so we didn't spend much time at the lake... We did enjoy the fireplace, the views, the amenities, and photographing the gorgeous sunsets on Seneca. The cottage was the perfect spot to launch our explorations of local wineries, Watkins Glen, and Geneva. Joe was wonderful to work with - he had to come out and thaw our frozen pipes one morning! It was my boyfriend & I - the bed (twin, convertible to king) was comfortable beyond our expectations. We did some cooking and found everything we needed in the well equipped kitchen. We hope to come back in the spring to take advantage of the lake & do some fishing. Recommended!

Responds fast! avg. 1 hour 30 minutes

Price per night from

$274

Charming Cottage on Cayuga Lake & Guest Cottage-- Pet Friendly

Romulus cottage

4 bedrooms / 4 bathrooms / sleeps 8

Responds fast! avg. 1 hour 34 minutes

Price per night from

$409

Responds fast! avg. 1 hour 7 minutes

Price per night from

$274

BEAT THE HEAT! DONAMEER GUEST COTTAGE /DOGS STAY FREE! Close 10/31/19

Hammondsport log cabin

1 bedroom / 2 bathrooms / sleeps 3

“Quiet country cottage” The cottage is located on a quiet horse farm in the rolling hills near Hammondsport, NY. There are many attractions within driving distance such as the Corning Glass Museum, Watkins Glen, the Glen Curtis Air Museum, wineries and beautiful vistas. The cottage is very well maintained, comfortable and spotless. Hosts Cynthia, Neil and their three Jack Russell dogs were welcoming and eager to have us enjoy our surroundings. If one is looking for a quiet, off the beaten path, accommodation I would say Donameer Farm fits the bill!

Responds fast! avg. 1 hour 57 minutes

Price per night from

$166

Unique and Secluded Waterfront Home with Private Cottage on 200' of Seneca Lake

Watkins Glen house

4 bedrooms / 3 bathrooms / sleeps 8

Responds fast! avg. 1 hour 39 minutes

Price per night from

$491

Locke's Glen on the Lake - Upper Level

Geneva house

2 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms / sleeps 4

Price per night from

$378

Charming Lakefront Cottage

Burdett house

2 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms / sleeps 4

Price per night from

$307

Seneca Lake Waterfront, Central to Wine Trail - Sleeps 6

Penn Yan cottage

3 bedrooms / 1 bathroom / sleeps 6

Responds fast! avg. 2 hours 56 minutes

Price per night from

$286

Geneva one story westside of Seneca Lake

Geneva house

3 bedrooms / 1 bathroom / sleeps 4

Price per night from

$332

Spacious Sanctuary in the Heart of Finger Lakes Wine Country

Watkins Glen apartment

2 bedrooms / 1 bathroom / sleeps 6

Price per night from

$212

Keuka Lake: Private, Updated, Steps to the Water!

Keuka Park house

4 bedrooms / 3 bathrooms / sleeps 12

“O'Cottage was so comfortable; I didn't want to leave!” I selected this location for a small family celebration because it was close to my parent's and my sister's homes. The living space in the cottage was much larger than I anticipated. So, it was perfect for entertaining! My immediate family gathered at O'Cottage to celebrate my son's high school graduation, 18th birthday and acceptance to Chapman University. My family enjoyed playing cornhole and cards along the water. My 13-year old and her friend had a lot of fun in the row boat. And, we all enjoyed making s'mores by the fire each evening. We rented a jet ski in Hammondsport and had a lovely dinner at the Tavern. Dinner at Seneca Farms and lunch at the Windmill were enjoyable. Hearing the sound of the waves splashing ashore from our bedrooms each night was amazing!

Responds fast! avg. 1 hour 49 minutes

Price per night from

$681

Cayuga Lake Home (Finger Lakes)

Romulus house

3 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms / sleeps 10

Price per night from

$287

Manor House Estate

Hammondsport manor house

5 bedrooms / 4 bathrooms / sleeps 16

Responds fast! avg. 3 hours 39 minutes

Price per night from

$911

Viewing 38 of 79
rentals in Starkey

×