Showing

PreviousNext property

$400

1 BR / 1 BA / Sleeps 4

Cherry Grove Oceanfront with Heated Pool - Fire Island vacation rentals
1 / 17

$400

Book

Cherry Grove Oceanfront with Heated Pool

1 BR / 1 BA / Sleeps 4 | Quick view

Details

Come join us in our fabulous get-a-way from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. This incredible "gay" oceanfront property is nestled in Cherry Grove, Long Island which hosts beautiful white sandy beaches. Sleep to the ocean waves by night and swim in our heated pool by day. Oversized modern kitchen, Private BBQ on…
  • Waterfront
  • Ocean or water views
  • Internet Access
  • Fireplace
  • Housekeeping Optional
  • Pet friendly
  • Suitable for the elderly
  • Wheelchair accessible

PreviousNext property

$250

1 BR / 1 BA / Sleeps 2

Fabulous cabana on the beach near NYC - Fire Island vacation rentals
1 / 6

$250

Book

Fabulous cabana on the beach near NYC

1 BR / 1 BA / Sleeps 2 | Quick view

Details

Just 90 minutes from Manhattan, but worlds away from NYC! In the Fire Island Pines, an idyllic gay community (but friendly to all) on the beach with no cars, just the deer roaming wild. The cabana is small but very self contained. BBQ on the deck overlooking the ocean. 5 minutes walk to "town" with bars …
  • Ocean or water views
  • Shared outdoor pool (unheated)
  • Hot Tub/Jacuzzi
  • Internet Access
  • Housekeeping Optional
  • Pet friendly - ask
  • Suitable for children - ask

PreviousNext property

$360

2 BR / 1 BA / Sleeps 4

Oceanfront House - 1/2 Share Summer 2015 - Fire Island vacation rentals
1 / 17

$360

Book

Oceanfront House - 1/2 Share Summer 2015

2 BR / 1 BA / Sleeps 4 | Quick view

Details

Long season in 2 bedroom unit in oceanfront house. Come join us in our fabulous get-a-way from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. This incredible "gay" oceanfront property is nestled in Cherry Grove, Long Island which hosts beautiful white sandy beaches. Sleep to the ocean waves by night and lounge on our …
  • Internet Access
  • Housekeeping Optional
  • Washing Machine
  • Clothes Dryer
  • Outdoor Dining Area
  • Pet friendly
  • Smoking allowed - ask
  • Suitable for children - ask
  • Suitable for the elderly - ask
  • Wheelchair accessible - ask

PreviousNext property

$572

3 BR / 2 BA / Sleeps 6

2 Reviews

$572

Book

Oceanfront Contemporary House - Fire Island

3 BR / 2 BA / Sleeps 6 | Quick view
“ Excellent ” 2 Reviews

Details

Reviews

(2)

Located in Lonelyville, Fire Island. Magnificent views - the best of the best, contemporary house built in the 90's. Rated one of the ten best island beaches in USA . Car free island, only bicycles. A safe place for children. Only 1 hour, 10 minutes by train, car or private van to ferry dock from New York City, or 15…
  • Waterfront
  • Ocean or water views
  • Internet Access
  • Washing Machine
  • Clothes Dryer
  • Suitable for children - over five
  • Suitable for the elderly

Details

Reviews

(2)

Wonderful views

Left on May 24, 2010 for a stay in June 2009

Fire Island is a place lost in time. Imagine a place without automobiles and the
deer roaming free on the island not afraid of humans. This very comfortable
house, it is well situated – right on the edge of a sand dune facing the ocean
with 180-degree unobstructed views. I would rent this house again in a
heartbeat.

PreviousNext property

$1,500

4 BR / 4 BA / Sleeps 8

Iconic Oceanfront house in the Fire Island Pines - Fire Island vacation rentals
1 / 16

$1,500

Book

Iconic Oceanfront house in the Fire Island Pines

4 BR / 4 BA / Sleeps 8 | Quick view

Details

Welcome to the Fire Island Pines. A gay community that is friendly to all. Beautiful beaches, great clubs, serenity steps from the beach. A view of the ocean from every room. Great for entertaining, or a quiet repose. All amenities included. A seven minute walk to the harbor. Enjoy a place with no cars, just …
  • Pet friendly - ask
  • Smoking allowed - ask
  • Suitable for children

PreviousNext property

$150

1 BR / 1 BA / Sleeps 2

2 Reviews

$150

Book

Twin bedroom shared bath

1 BR / 1 BA / Sleeps 2 | Quick view
“ Excellent ” 2 Reviews

Details

Reviews

(2)

(email: hidden) Pines Paradise B. is a gay guesthouse in Fire Island Pines, a gay community off the coast of Long Island. We offer spectacular views of the ocean and the bay for both sunset vistas and moonlit nights. The guest house features plenty of private and public space. Whether your idea of relaxation is a …
  • Waterfront
  • Ocean or water views
  • Shared outdoor pool (unheated)
  • Hot Tub/Jacuzzi
  • Internet Access
  • Pet friendly - ask
  • Smoking allowed - ask
  • Suitable for children - ask
  • Suitable for the elderly - ask
  • Wheelchair accessible - ask

Details

Reviews

(2)

Perfect for groups---beach mere steps away !!!

Left on Aug 20, 2014 for a stay in August 2014

Absolutely the finest rental I've ever found on Fire Island. Joe, the host, makes you feel so welcome with the most spacious and upgraded accommodations and a fantastic food & beverage package that pays for itself in your first two meals! Beautiful linens and towels, flat screen TVs with AppleTV, free wifi, well appointed bathrooms, an open-air shower option plus full indoor bathrooms, as well. …

PreviousNext property

$200

1 BR / 1 BA / Sleeps 2

3 Reviews

$200

Book

Queen bedroom private bath

1 BR / 1 BA / Sleeps 2 | Quick view
“ Excellent ” 3 Reviews

Details

Reviews

(3)

(email: hidden) Pines Paradise B. is a gay guesthouse in Fire Island Pines, a gay community off the coast of Long Island. We offer spectacular views of the ocean and the bay for both sunset vistas and moonlit nights. The guest house features plenty of private and public space. Whether your idea of relaxation is a …
  • Waterfront
  • Ocean or water views
  • Shared outdoor pool (unheated)
  • Hot Tub/Jacuzzi
  • Internet Access
  • Pet friendly - ask
  • Smoking allowed - ask
  • Suitable for children - ask
  • Suitable for the elderly - ask
  • Wheelchair accessible - ask

Details

Reviews

(3)

Fantastic experience---highly recommended lodging !!!

Left on Aug 20, 2014 for a stay in July 2014

Absolutely the finest rental I've ever found on Fire Island. Joe, the host, makes you feel so welcome with the most spacious and upgraded accommodations and a fantastic food & beverage package that pays for itself in your first two meals! Beautiful linens and towels, flat screen TVs with AppleTV, free wifi, well appointed bathrooms, an open-air shower option plus full indoor bathrooms, as well. …

PreviousNext property

$580

4 BR / 3 BA / Sleeps 10

1 / 18

$580

Inquire

Magnificent Ocean beach Home -Ready for the Summer

4 BR / 3 BA / Sleeps 10 | Quick view

Details

Magnificent Home Completely Remodeled And Ready For Vacation in Ocean Beach. This impeccably crafted property features 4 bedrooms, 3 full bathrooms, and a swimming pool! Luxurious master suite with private balcony, walk in closet, and stunning bathroom with large walk in shower with double shower heads, and deep …
  • Ocean or water views
  • Fireplace
  • Housekeeping Optional
  • Washing Machine
  • Clothes Dryer
  • Suitable for children - ask
  • Suitable for the elderly - ask

PreviousNext property

$400

4 BR / 1 BA / Sleeps 7

1 / 11

$400

Inquire

4-bedroom home, 7 houses from beach in Ocean Beach

4 BR / 1 BA / Sleeps 7 | Quick view

Details

WE ARE RENTED FOR SUMMER 2014 Thank you for your interest. Town rules require MINIMUM ONE-WEEK RENTALS. This one-level house includes four bedrooms and one bathroom. It is for FAMILIES ONLY, AND NO PETS ARE ALLOWED(sorry, our daughter has serious allergies). There's a brand-new outside shower on the deck.The bathroom…
  • Internet Access
  • Washing Machine
  • Clothes Dryer
  • Outdoor Dining Area
  • A/C or climate control
  • Suitable for children
  • Suitable for the elderly
  • Wheelchair accessible - ask

PreviousNext property

$200

1 BR / 1 BA / Sleeps 2

1 Reviews

$200

Book

Full bedroom shared bath

1 BR / 1 BA / Sleeps 2 | Quick view
“ Excellent ” 1 Reviews

Details

Reviews

(1)

(email: hidden) Pines Paradise B. is a gay guesthouse in Fire Island Pines, a gay community off the coast of Long Island. We offer spectacular views of the ocean and the bay for both sunset vistas and moonlit nights. The guest house features plenty of private and public space. Whether your idea of relaxation is a …
  • Waterfront
  • Ocean or water views
  • Shared outdoor pool (unheated)
  • Hot Tub/Jacuzzi
  • Internet Access
  • Pet friendly - ask
  • Smoking allowed - ask
  • Suitable for children - ask
  • Suitable for the elderly - ask
  • Wheelchair accessible - ask

Details

Reviews

(1)

Definitely a stay I'd do again!

Left on Aug 15, 2014 for a stay in August 2014

So comfortable and peaceful! Living a NYC you can get amped up by the tiniest thing... And believe me, I tried to keep working when I got there, but Joe and the other guests got me into a calm place and the rest of my stay was about good food, laying out on the beach and random walks around the island.

PreviousNext property

$315

2 BR / 1 BA / Sleeps 4

1 / 2

$315

Book

Cherry Grove Fire Island Beach getaway!

2 BR / 1 BA / Sleeps 4 | Quick view

Details

Sweeping views of th Great South Bay from this 2 BR, 1-1/2 bath gem. Get your friends and your beach towels an think BEACH right now!

PreviousNext property

$300

1 BR / 4 BA / Sleeps 2

4 Reviews

$300

Book

Fire Island Pines Retreat

1 BR / 4 BA / Sleeps 2 | Quick view
“ Excellent ” 4 Reviews

Details

Reviews

(4)

Welcome to Fire Island Pines Retreat. We are a gay guesthouse on Fire Island Pines, a gay community off the coast of Long Island. We pride ourselves on offering extremely comfortable accommodations at reasonable prices, and look forward to welcoming you to Fire Island Pines. Our home is very modern, featuring …
  • Waterfront
  • Ocean or water views
  • Shared outdoor pool (unheated)
  • Hot Tub/Jacuzzi
  • Internet Access
  • Pet friendly - ask
  • Smoking allowed - ask
  • Suitable for children - ask
  • Suitable for the elderly - ask
  • Wheelchair accessible - ask

Details

Reviews

(4)

REVIVE IN PARADISE; THE MOST BEAUTIFUL STAY IN THE PINES

Left on Jul 30, 2014 for a stay in July 2014

Absolutely the finest rental I've ever found on Fire Island. Joe, the host, makes you feel so welcome with the most spacious and upgraded accommodations and a fantastic food & beverage package that pays for itself in your first two meals! Beautiful linens and towels, flat screen TVs with AppleTV, free wifi, well appointed bathrooms, an open-air shower option plus full indoor bathrooms, as …

PreviousNext property

$375

4 BR / 2 BA / Sleeps 8

1 Reviews

$375

Book

Kismet Fire Island - Lovely beach house

4 BR / 2 BA / Sleeps 8 | Quick view
“ Excellent ” 1 Reviews

Details

Reviews

(1)

Our wonderful cottage comes with all the expected amenities for the total vacation experience. It has two decks, a large private rear deck and fun smaller front deck for people watchers . Fire Island boasts no private cars in the summer until Sept 15 so the kids have freedom to wander safely after you travel by ferry …
  • Wireless Internet
  • Housekeeping Optional
  • Washing Machine
  • Clothes Dryer
  • Outdoor Dining Area
  • Suitable for children
  • Suitable for the elderly
  • Wheelchair accessible

Details

Reviews

(1)

Clean updated house with all amentities, A/C and great location. Great Beach.

Left on Aug 12, 2014 for a stay in July 2013

Great cottage in Kismet - good, convenient location - easy walk to bay/shops, water taxi/ferry & and beach. Property is clean, updated and open. Nice floors and paint colors - very beachy. Outdoor shower is awesome. Huge back deck. Well stocked and has all amenities. 3 decent sized full bedrooms, one smaller bunk room - best for kids only. Kismet can be noisy at night during busy season, so A/C…

PreviousNext property

$917

5 BR / 3 BA / Sleeps 10

1 / 34

$917

Book

BEAUTIFUL 5 BEDROOM HOME IN FIRE ISLAND!

5 BR / 3 BA / Sleeps 10 | Quick view

Details

NEWLY RENOVATED--CLOSE TO TOWN--VERY LARGE SIDE YARD--5 BEDROOMS--2 1/2 BATHROOMS--OUTSIDE SHOWER--WASHER/DRYER ROOM--SPACIOUS LVIING ROOM--10 PERSON DINING ROOM TABLE--STAINLESS STEEL APPLIANCES--GRANITE COUNTERTOPS--PILLOW TOP MATTRESSES--OUTSIDE DECK THIS HOUSE IS AVAILABLE FOR THE 2015 SEASON FROM MAY 15TH TO …
  • Internet Access
  • Fireplace
  • Washing Machine
  • Clothes Dryer
  • Outdoor Dining Area
  • Pet friendly - ask
  • Suitable for children

PreviousNext property

$1,200

4 BR / 3 BA / Sleeps 8

1 Reviews

$1,200

Book

Spect. 4 bd, 3 bth oceanft. house, Fire Island, NY

4 BR / 3 BA / Sleeps 8 | Quick view
“ Excellent ” 1 Reviews

Details

Reviews

(1)

Contemporary furn. beach house steps to ocean, 5 mins to bay. Ideal for two families, Accomodates 8 persons inc. children. No groups! Hose features oudtoor shower, gas grill, two decks, gas grill, flat screen tv,dvd,vcr. fully equipped kitchen, washer, dryer, wireless internet avail. Tranquil family community, …
  • Deck
  • Books
  • Satellite or cable TV
  • Television
  • DVD Player
  • Pet friendly
  • Suitable for children - ask

Details

Reviews

(1)

Beautiful house on the beach

Left on Jul 12, 2010 for a stay in July 2010

I had a wonderful time staying at this property, just steps from the beach in Dunewood. The house was roomy and comfortable, and it was so great to be able to walk just a few steps to get to the ocean. My wife and baby daughter also enjoyed themselves tremendously. I can't wait to visit again.


Looking for more rentals?


We're showing only results that match your dates and preferences.


See all 15 Fire Island rentals, all 100 Long Island rentals, or start a new search.


There are no more results in Fire Island. Top of page