Updating...
Relevance
Price: low to high
Price: high to low
Number of reviews
137 apartments
Responds fast! avg. 5 minutes
Price per night from
$297
Beautifully Renovated 'Pinebrook Cottage' 2BR 1BA Secluded, Beach Close
New Buffalo house
2 bedrooms / 1 bathroom / sleeps 6
Responds fast! avg. 2 hours 58 minutes
Price per night from
$243
Designer Luxury, Walk to Everything ~ Private Hot Tub, Perfect for Large Family
New Buffalo house
4 bedrooms / 4 bathrooms / sleeps 12
Price per night from
$648
5* rated. Block to Lake MI. Golf Cart (seasonal). Secluded.
New Buffalo house
3 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms / sleeps 9
Responds fast! avg. 2 hours 29 minutes
Price per night from
$232
'The Peachtree Cottage' w/ Hot Tub in New Buffalo!
New Buffalo cottage
3 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms / sleeps 8
Responds fast! avg. 5 minutes
Price per night from
$190
Everything Is New From Beds To Kitchen Cabinets
New Buffalo cottage
2 bedrooms / 1 bathroom / sleeps 6
Responds fast! avg. 1 hour 32 minutes
Price per night from
$260
Responds fast! avg. 1 hour 35 minutes
Price per night from
$203
Brand new home - 4 bedrooms, 3.5 baths. Walk to EVERYTHING in NB!! Sleeps 12!
New Buffalo house
4 bedrooms / 4 bathrooms / sleeps 12
Price per night from
$695
"Holiday Heaven"- pool home 4 full week summer vacations & off season wknds
New Buffalo house
4 bedrooms / 4 bathrooms / sleeps 14
Price per night from
$637
Great rentals within 20 miles that match your search
Great multi-family home,1st floor master, 6 bedrooms, fireplace, golf cart.
Michigan City house
6 bedrooms / 3 bathrooms / sleeps 13
Price per night from
$745
Price per night from
$2,074
Responds fast! avg. 3 hours 32 minutes
Price per night from
$693
Price per night from
$232
4BR 3BA Short Walk to Beach - New Furnishings 8/15
Michigan City house
4 bedrooms / 3 bathrooms / sleeps 14
Price per night from
$637
Crown Jewel--Size and Luxury as Featured in Coastal Living
Michigan City house
9 bedrooms / 7 bathrooms / sleeps 24
Responds fast! avg. 52 minutes
Price per night from
$577
Sun King--Brand New 6th Full Bathroom!--Huge Beautiful Home
Michigan City house
7 bedrooms / 6 bathrooms / sleeps 24
“What an awesome space to be together with family!” There was plenty of room and space for everyone and everything! -- A wrap around porch, two LARGE dining areas, plenty of counter space in the kitchen with a large island as well (with stools for more seating), a finished basement with a family room and toys including a large "play" area. Just check out all the included amenities! Being grandma and grandpa we stayed in the "Jester" and had our own apartment. We also loved that it was a short drive (one hour from Chicago) and the short walk to the beach. Loved the area and plan to visit the Sun King again. Once you get there...you will never want to leave.
Responds fast! avg. 52 minutes
Price per night from
$455
Price per night from
$608
Michiana Shores Cottage 2BR 2BA - Walk to Beach!
Michiana Shores house
2 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms / sleeps 7
Price per night from
$416
Lighthouse apt. Great location right by Lighthouse Outlet Mall See the Sale!
Michigan City apartment
1 bedroom / 1 bathroom / sleeps 3
“Great stay!!” This apartment was perfect for our vacation. The location is great (right by the outlets and many restaurants)! The kids loved it and Darlene was a wonderful host (thanks for the cookies!!) I would highly recommend this rental to anyone. Just know that for Wi-Fi you have to go across the street to the Coffee Shop or down the road to Starbucks. :)
Price per night from
$145
Price per night from
$289
Two-Bedroom Apartment by Lighthouse Outlet Mall
Michigan City apartment
2 bedrooms / 1 bathroom / sleeps 4
Price per night from
$174
Price per night from
$434
A Quaint Country Cottage in Scenic Harbor Country!
Union Pier cottage
3 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms / sleeps 10
Price per night from
$307
Responds fast! avg. 7 minutes
Price per night from
$521
Beautiful apt. across from Lighthouse Mall
Michigan City apartment
1 bedroom / 1 bathroom / sleeps 2
“I love it!” Had an amazing weekend away it was perfect! Busy everyday doing something fun, got to enjoy the beach, the mall, had really good tasting food and everyone was super nice around town!
Price per night from
$145
Luxury Beachfront Condo on Beautiful Lake Michigan! Rooftop Patio!
Michigan City condo
3 bedrooms / 3 bathrooms / sleeps 12
Price per night from
$1,041
Southern Belle in Beachwalk Resort Community!
Michigan City house
5 bedrooms / 5 bathrooms / sleeps 14
Responds fast! avg. 3 hours 32 minutes
Price per night from
$463
Charming, Updated Sawyer Dune Cottage--Next to Warren Dunes + Private Beach!
Sawyer cottage
3 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms / sleeps 8
Price per night from
$319
Poseidon--Beachwalk's Largest Home. The King of Beachwalk.
Michigan City house
8 bedrooms / 6 bathrooms / sleeps 27
Responds fast! avg. 52 minutes
Price per night from
$455
Beautiful apt next to Lighthouse Outlet Mall
Michigan City apartment
1 bedroom / 1 bathroom / sleeps 3
“Beautiful Apartment and Darlene was Awesome.” My husband and I arrived at the apartments for a 2 night stay and was greeted by the owner Darlene. She later came back to our unit with cans of pop, water and she even make us home made chocolate cookies! The place was very cozy and clean and was easy to access the outlets, beach and many other places. Highly recommend! Where else would you get this kind of treatment...Darlene you are a sweetheart and a great Hostess!!!!
Price per night from
$145
Responds fast! avg. 1 hour 0 minutes
Price per night from
$590
Viewing 38 of 137
rentals in New Buffalo
About New Buffalo
Between the coast of Lake Michigan and the rolling farms in the southwest corner of the state, two historic roadways intersect in the quaint, laid-back, beach town of New Buffalo. New Buffalo lies within a stone's throw of the Indiana border and about 90 minutes from the bustle of Chicago, but it feels like a quiet step out of time.
Come here to explore the antique shops on Red Arrow and Buffalo Street. Try your luck at the Four Winds Casino, Michigan's very first casino, which opened in 2007. Come for the delicious food and annual fun of Greek Fest, or the carnival rides and games of St. Mary's Summer Festival on Memorial Day weekend. Or just relax on the shores of Lake Michigan, watch the sunset, and then explore the award winning but unpretentious restaurants along the coast.
There are plenty of indoor activities here, including world-class spas and charming local museums. There are also biking and hiking paths, golf courses and local parks. You'll never run out of fun things to do in New Buffalo.
Here are a few additional suggestions as you plan your trip:
- Explore Lake Michigan: The beaches along the New Buffalo shoreline are a perfect place to swim, relax, or go fishing for trout and perch.
- Rent a boat or WaveRunner: Boating is a way of life here. Rent a canoe or motorboat and launch from the New Buffalo public marina.
- Visit the New Buffalo Railroad Museum: Learn more about the important role of railroads and steam engines in the history of southern Michigan. The museum includes a working miniature railroad display and is a must for train lovers.
- Take a bicycle tour of Lake Michigan: Rent a bicycle or bring your own and explore the scenic areas along the boardwalk and harbor marina.
- Hike the trails: Head just south of the Indiana border and explore the Indiana Dunes National Lakeshore.
- Enjoy the nightlife: Explore the first class shopping and dining venues along Buffalo Street and Marquette Drive.
There are plenty of things to do and places to stay in New Buffalo. You'll have no trouble finding the perfect vacation rental here that offers everything you and your family need. Book a lakeside condo within a few steps of the beach, or rent an apartment close to the shopping and dining areas downtown.
Top Destination reviews
Also consider
- Union Pier 21 properties
- Sawyer 10 properties
- Lakeside 5 properties
- Upper Peninsula 253 properties
- Leelanau County 69 properties
- Benzie County 45 properties
- Antrim County 40 properties
- Ottawa County 31 properties
- Ludington 17 properties
- Lewiston 12 properties
- Tawas City 11 properties
- Kalkaska County 11 properties
- Osceola County 8 properties
- Houghton Lake 8 properties
- Clare County 8 properties
- Branch County 7 properties
- Cass County 7 properties
- Lake County 6 properties
- Houghton Lake Heights 5 properties
- Wequetonsing 5 properties
- Roscommon 5 properties
- Royal Oak 5 properties
- Monroe 5 properties