Vacation Rentals & House Rentals in Fire Island

Close

Enter dates for more accurate prices

Payment Protection
Your payment for this rental is protected when you pay through FlipKey. Learn more

39 house rentals

    24

    Fire Island Home Across the Street from the Beach!

    Long Island / Fire Island

    Fire Island house

    4 8 min stay varies

    • 4 bedrooms
    • sleeps 8
    • min stay varies
    • Child Friendly
    • Pet Friendly

    Price per night from

    $172

    Responds fast!
    avg. 9 minutes

    Price per night from

    $172

      24

      NEW! Cozy Fire Island Studio - Steps to the Beach!

      Fire Island / Ocean Beach

      Ocean Beach studio

      Studio 2 min stay varies

      • Studio
      • sleeps 2
      • min stay varies
      • Child Friendly
      • Air conditioning

      Price per night from

      $132

      Responds fast!
      avg. 9 minutes

      Price per night from

      $132

        13

        Oceanfront Luxury Retreat

        Fire Island / Ocean Bay Park

        Ocean Bay Park house

        5 12 3 nights min

        • 5 bedrooms
        • sleeps 12
        • 3 nights min
        • Child Friendly

        Price per night from

        $2,290

        Price per night from

        $2,290

          19

          Charming Bay View Cottage

          Fire Island / Ocean Beach

          Ocean Beach cottage

          2 5 min stay varies

          • 2 bedrooms
          • sleeps 5
          • min stay varies
          • Child Friendly
          • Air conditioning
          • Pet Friendly

          Price per night from

          $456

          Price per night from

          $456

          (1) Excellent 

            23

            Cherry Grove Oceanfront with Heated Pool

            Fire Island / Cherry Grove

            Cherry Grove house

            1 4 7 nights min

            • 1 bedroom
            • sleeps 4
            • 7 nights min
            • Beach / lakeside relaxation
            • Swimming pool
            • Car not necessary

            Price per night from

            $573

            Price per night from

            $573

            (1) Very Good 

              16

              Fair Harbor, Fire Island,NY 3 brdrooms plus an open loft. paradise near the bay

              Fire Island / Fair Harbor

              Fair Harbor house

              4 7 3 nights min

              • 4 bedrooms
              • sleeps 7
              • 3 nights min
              • Beach / lakeside relaxation
              • Nearest beach 0.16 mi
              • Child Friendly

              Price per night from

              $859

              Price per night from

              $859

                8

                Summer 2019 - steps from the ocean

                Fire Island / Ocean Beach

                Ocean Beach house

                4 8 min stay varies

                • 4 bedrooms
                • sleeps 8
                • min stay varies
                • Child Friendly
                • Car not necessary
                • Pet Friendly

                Price per night from

                $1,645

                Price per night from

                $1,645

                (3) Average 

                  33

                  Blue Parrot 3 Bedroom, 1 bath, large deck, wi-fi, sat TV, d/w, microwave

                  Fire Island / Ocean Beach

                  Ocean Beach apartment

                  3 8 3 nights min

                  • 3 bedrooms
                  • sleeps 8
                  • 3 nights min
                  • Nearest beach 0.2 mi
                  • Child Friendly
                  • Car not necessary

                  Price per night from

                  $342

                  Responds fast!
                  avg. 1 hour 16 minutes

                  Price per night from

                  $342

                  (7) Excellent 

                    25

                    Adorable home with Large PRIVATE deck- Fire Island

                    Fire Island / Kismet

                    Kismet house

                    4 8 7 nights min

                    • 4 bedrooms
                    • sleeps 8
                    • 7 nights min
                    • Beach / lakeside relaxation
                    • Nearest beach 0.16 mi
                    • Child Friendly

                    Price per night from

                    $570

                    Responds fast!
                    avg. 3 hours 59 minutes

                    Price per night from

                    $570

                      9

                      Great Family Rental - Sun Sand and Surf!

                      Fire Island / Ocean Beach

                      Ocean Beach house

                      4 10 6 nights min

                      • 4 bedrooms
                      • sleeps 10
                      • 6 nights min
                      • Air conditioning
                      • Pet Friendly

                      Price per night from

                      $991

                      Responds fast!
                      avg. 49 minutes

                      Price per night from

                      $991

                      (1) Very Good 

                        24

                        Fire Island Home-Deck, Grill & Stunning Bay Views!

                        Long Island / Fire Island

                        Fire Island house

                        4 12 min stay varies

                        • 4 bedrooms
                        • sleeps 12
                        • min stay varies
                        • Child Friendly
                        • Air conditioning

                        Price per night from

                        $573

                        Responds fast!
                        avg. 9 minutes

                        Price per night from

                        $573

                          27

                          NEW! Ocean Beach Home w/Outdoor Shower & Deck!

                          Fire Island / Ocean Beach

                          Ocean Beach house

                          3 6 6 nights min

                          • 3 bedrooms
                          • sleeps 6
                          • 6 nights min
                          • Child Friendly
                          • Air conditioning
                          • Pet Friendly

                          Price per night from

                          $630

                          Responds fast!
                          avg. 9 minutes

                          Price per night from

                          $630

                            14

                            Charming Fire Island House (Seaview) - Private Deck - Family Friendly

                            Long Island / Fire Island

                            Fire Island house

                            3 8 6 nights min

                            • 3 bedrooms
                            • sleeps 8
                            • 6 nights min
                            • Child Friendly
                            • Pet Friendly
                            • Private garden

                            Price per night from

                            $859

                            Price per night from

                            $859

                              23

                              Great 2 Bedroom Oceanfront House

                              Fire Island / Cherry Grove

                              Cherry Grove house

                              2 4 7 nights min

                              • 2 bedrooms
                              • sleeps 4
                              • 7 nights min
                              • Beach / lakeside relaxation
                              • Nearest beach 0 mi
                              • Ask about children

                              Price per night from

                              $456

                              Price per night from

                              $456

                                12

                                Fire island beach house

                                Fire Island / Ocean Beach

                                Ocean Beach house

                                4 10 7 nights min

                                • 4 bedrooms
                                • sleeps 10
                                • 7 nights min
                                • Child Friendly
                                • Pet Friendly

                                Price per night from

                                $900

                                Price per night from

                                $900

                                  9

                                  Sunny Ocean Bay Park (Fire Island) Beach Apartment - Short walk to beach.

                                  Fire Island / Ocean Bay Park

                                  Ocean Bay Park apartment

                                  3 6 4 nights min

                                  • 3 bedrooms
                                  • sleeps 6
                                  • 4 nights min
                                  • Child Friendly

                                  Price per night from

                                  $653

                                  Price per night from

                                  $653

                                    8

                                    Perfect beach house

                                    Fire Island / Ocean Bay Park

                                    Ocean Bay Park house

                                    4 12 min stay varies

                                    • 4 bedrooms
                                    • sleeps 12
                                    • min stay varies
                                    • Child Friendly
                                    • Air conditioning

                                    Price per night from

                                    $630

                                    Price per night from

                                    $630

                                      4

                                      Mermaid house

                                      Fire Island / Ocean Beach

                                      Ocean Beach house

                                      4 10 min stay varies

                                      • 4 bedrooms
                                      • sleeps 10
                                      • min stay varies
                                      • Child Friendly
                                      • Air conditioning

                                      Price per night from

                                      $513

                                      Price per night from

                                      $513

                                        10

                                        Newly renovated

                                        Fire Island / Ocean Bay Park

                                        Ocean Bay Park house

                                        5 13 min stay varies

                                        • 5 bedrooms
                                        • sleeps 13
                                        • min stay varies
                                        • Child Friendly
                                        • Air conditioning

                                        Price per night from

                                        $738

                                        Price per night from

                                        $738

                                          19

                                          COOL SUMMER BEACH HOUSE

                                          Fire Island / Ocean Beach

                                          Ocean Beach house

                                          5 10 min stay varies

                                          • 5 bedrooms
                                          • sleeps 10
                                          • min stay varies
                                          • Child Friendly
                                          • Air conditioning
                                          • Private garden

                                          Price per night from

                                          $911

                                          Price per night from

                                          $911

                                            21

                                            Fire Island Cottage-3Bed2Bath

                                            Fire Island / Fair Harbor

                                            Fair Harbor cottage

                                            3 6 6 nights min

                                            • 3 bedrooms
                                            • sleeps 6
                                            • 6 nights min
                                            • Beach / lakeside relaxation
                                            • Nearest beach 0.1 mi
                                            • Child Friendly

                                            Price per night from

                                            $968

                                            Price per night from

                                            $968

                                              14

                                              Fire Island New York - 3 Bed

                                              Long Island / Fire Island

                                              Fire Island cottage

                                              3 6 30 nights min

                                              • 3 bedrooms
                                              • sleeps 6
                                              • 30 nights min
                                              • Beach / lakeside relaxation
                                              • Suitable for children age 5+
                                              • Car not necessary

                                              Price per night from

                                              $753

                                              Price per night from

                                              $753

                                              Great rentals within 20 miles that match your search

                                              Distance approx 10.99 km from Fire Island

                                                27

                                                "Above the Bay" - Suite-Bedrm ,Den,Bath & Kitchen

                                                Long Island / East Patchogue

                                                East Patchogue apartment

                                                1 2 3 nights min

                                                • 1 bedroom
                                                • sleeps 2
                                                • 3 nights min
                                                • Air conditioning
                                                • Private garden

                                                Price per night from

                                                $166

                                                Price per night from

                                                $166

                                                Distance approx 13.81 km from Fire Island

                                                  31

                                                  Rent entire house with 6 bedrooms

                                                  Long Island / West Babylon

                                                  West Babylon house

                                                  6 14 1 night min

                                                  • 6 bedrooms
                                                  • sleeps 14
                                                  • 1 night min
                                                  • Child Friendly
                                                  • Air conditioning
                                                  • Private garden

                                                  Price per night from

                                                  $171

                                                  Responds fast!
                                                  avg. 53 minutes

                                                  Price per night from

                                                  $171

                                                  Distance approx 16.78 km from Fire Island

                                                    21

                                                    Perfect summer haven, ten minutes walk to village

                                                    Long Island / Bellport

                                                    Bellport house

                                                    3 10 4 nights min

                                                    • 3 bedrooms
                                                    • sleeps 10
                                                    • 4 nights min
                                                    • Swimming pool
                                                    • Child Friendly
                                                    • Air conditioning

                                                    Price per night from

                                                    $681

                                                    Price per night from

                                                    $681

                                                    Distance approx 10.71 km from Fire Island

                                                    (1) Excellent 

                                                      20

                                                      Beautiful Relaxing Sun Room

                                                      Long Island / West Babylon

                                                      West Babylon house

                                                      1 4 1 night min

                                                      • 1 bedroom
                                                      • sleeps 4
                                                      • 1 night min

                                                      Price per night from

                                                      $92

                                                      Price per night from

                                                      $92

                                                      Distance approx 15.97 km from Fire Island

                                                        51

                                                        Frank Lloyd Wright Prairie Style Home on 4 Acres Wild Life Refuge

                                                        Long Island / Brookhaven

                                                        Brookhaven house

                                                        5 15 3 nights min

                                                        • 5 bedrooms
                                                        • sleeps 15
                                                        • 3 nights min
                                                        • Child Friendly
                                                        • Air conditioning
                                                        • Pet Friendly

                                                        Price per night from

                                                        $564

                                                        Responds fast!
                                                        avg. 1 hour 24 minutes

                                                        Price per night from

                                                        $564

                                                        Distance approx 19.49 km from Fire Island

                                                        (1) Excellent 

                                                          9

                                                          Central Location to Long Island Attractions

                                                          Long Island / Coram

                                                          Coram house

                                                          2 4 4 nights min

                                                          • 2 bedrooms
                                                          • sleeps 4
                                                          • 4 nights min
                                                          • Air conditioning
                                                          • Private garden

                                                          Price per night from

                                                          $143

                                                          Price per night from

                                                          $143

                                                          Distance approx 18.64 km from Fire Island

                                                          (4) Excellent 

                                                            16

                                                            Ground floor sunlit apt. in great area!

                                                            Long Island / Huntington

                                                            Huntington apartment

                                                            1 4 1 night min

                                                            • 1 bedroom
                                                            • sleeps 4
                                                            • 1 night min
                                                            • Swimming pool
                                                            • Ask about children
                                                            • Ask about pets

                                                            Price per night from

                                                            $97

                                                            Responds fast!
                                                            avg. 3 hours 8 minutes

                                                            Price per night from

                                                            $97

                                                            Distance approx 19.79 km from Fire Island

                                                              4

                                                              Beautiful 2 bedroom apartment very cozy and comfortable with unlimited parking..

                                                              Long Island / Middle Island

                                                              Middle Island apartment

                                                              2 6 1 night min

                                                              • 2 bedrooms
                                                              • sleeps 6
                                                              • 1 night min
                                                              • Child Friendly
                                                              • Air conditioning
                                                              • Pet Friendly

                                                              Price per night from

                                                              $184

                                                              Price per night from

                                                              $184

                                                              Distance approx 19.63 km from Fire Island

                                                                16

                                                                Charming Room - Private Entrance

                                                                Long Island / Levittown

                                                                Levittown room

                                                                1 4 30 nights min

                                                                • 1 bedroom
                                                                • sleeps 4
                                                                • 30 nights min
                                                                • Nearest beach 19 mi
                                                                • Child Friendly
                                                                • Air conditioning

                                                                Price per night from

                                                                $56

                                                                Responds fast!
                                                                avg. 2 hours 47 minutes

                                                                Price per night from

                                                                $56

                                                                Distance approx 12.86 km from Fire Island

                                                                  6

                                                                  Cheaper Than a Hotel! Spacious Guest Suite in Medford, Long Island

                                                                  Long Island / Medford

                                                                  Medford room

                                                                  1 2 1 night min

                                                                  • 1 bedroom
                                                                  • sleeps 2
                                                                  • 1 night min
                                                                  • Child Friendly
                                                                  • Air conditioning
                                                                  • Pet Friendly

                                                                  Price per night from

                                                                  $86

                                                                  Price per night from

                                                                  $86

                                                                  Distance approx 13.44 km from Fire Island

                                                                    24

                                                                    NEW! Charming 2BR Bellport Cottage - 5 Min to Bay!

                                                                    Long Island / Bellport

                                                                    Bellport cottage

                                                                    2 6 min stay varies

                                                                    • 2 bedrooms
                                                                    • sleeps 6
                                                                    • min stay varies
                                                                    • Suitable for children age 5+
                                                                    • Air conditioning
                                                                    • Pet Friendly

                                                                    Price per night from

                                                                    $200

                                                                    Responds fast!
                                                                    avg. 9 minutes

                                                                    Price per night from

                                                                    $200

                                                                    Distance approx 17.12 km from Fire Island

                                                                      50

                                                                      Panoramic Beauty

                                                                      Long Island / Mastic Beach

                                                                      Mastic Beach cottage

                                                                      1 4 1 night min

                                                                      • 1 bedroom
                                                                      • sleeps 4
                                                                      • 1 night min
                                                                      • Air conditioning
                                                                      • Private garden

                                                                      Price per night from

                                                                      $103

                                                                      Price per night from

                                                                      $103

                                                                      Distance approx 13.01 km from Fire Island

                                                                        37

                                                                        Sandy Toes - A 2 bed/1 bath private therapeutic pool home & pet friendly!

                                                                        Long Island / Copiague

                                                                        Copiague apartment

                                                                        2 4 min stay varies

                                                                        • 2 bedrooms
                                                                        • sleeps 4
                                                                        • min stay varies
                                                                        • Swimming pool
                                                                        • Ask about children
                                                                        • Air conditioning

                                                                        Price per night from

                                                                        $129

                                                                        Responds fast!
                                                                        avg. 3 hours 41 minutes

                                                                        Price per night from

                                                                        $129

                                                                        Distance approx 17.68 km from Fire Island

                                                                          8

                                                                          BLISSFUL LUXURY | Private Room w/Hotel Amenities

                                                                          Long Island / Greenlawn

                                                                          Greenlawn room

                                                                          1 2 2 nights min

                                                                          • 1 bedroom
                                                                          • sleeps 2
                                                                          • 2 nights min

                                                                          Price per night from

                                                                          $98

                                                                          Price per night from

                                                                          $98

                                                                          Distance approx 16 km from Fire Island

                                                                            35

                                                                            Nelly home

                                                                            Long Island / Mastic Beach

                                                                            Mastic Beach house

                                                                            2 4 1 night min

                                                                            • 2 bedrooms
                                                                            • sleeps 4
                                                                            • 1 night min
                                                                            • Nearest beach 0 mi
                                                                            • Child Friendly

                                                                            Price per night from

                                                                            $350

                                                                            Price per night from

                                                                            $350

                                                                            Distance approx 11.82 km from Fire Island

                                                                              7

                                                                              Studio + Your Own Bar

                                                                              Long Island / Brentwood

                                                                              Brentwood studio

                                                                              Studio 2 1 night min

                                                                              • Studio
                                                                              • sleeps 2
                                                                              • 1 night min
                                                                              • Air conditioning

                                                                              Price per night from

                                                                              $126

                                                                              Price per night from

                                                                              $126

                                                                              About Fire Island

                                                                              Free of cars and chaos, the island community known as Fire Island is where city dwellers go to escape for the weekend and enjoy beautiful beaches and a laid-back atmosphere. The areas around Bay Walk are your best bet for outdoor attractions and fine dining. However, there are lots of cultural activities and historical sites that can be found almost everywhere in Fire Island.

                                                                              Here are just a few of the activities and sites you should make time for during your stay:

                                                                              • Go Boating: With over 100 miles of coastline, it's no surprise that people here frequently rent a boat for the afternoon and hit the water.
                                                                              • Cherry Grove: This vibrant Fire Island community plays host to some of the biggest performances and parties on the island all year.
                                                                              • Sunken Forest: This primordial forest filled with wooden walkways is the perfect place to get away from the bustling beach community for an afternoon.
                                                                              • Go to the Beach: A vacation to Fire Island wouldn't be complete without spending some time on the miles of beautiful white sand beaches that the area has to offer.

                                                                              You can find live music and a wide range of interesting performers throughout Fire Island most nights of the week. However, the biggest events festivals in town typically take place during the spring and summer months. Enjoy the marquee party of the year on the island, known as Ascension, held every August, admire the over-the-top fireworks proceedings during the Fourth of July festivities, or watch some of the best dancers in the state strut their stuff during the Fire Island Dance Festival in July.

                                                                              A vacation rental is the preferred option for those staying in Fire Island. Rent a beautiful villa with beach views perfect for a Fire Island wedding, or a luxury condo near some of the most popular dining options amongst the locals. You can also book a rustic cabin in one of the more remote parts of the island for a Fire Island romantic getaway.

                                                                              If you have some extra time to explore the surrounding area, the quiet towns throughout Long Island and the bustling metropolis of New York City can both be reached within 90 minutes by car.