Updating...
Relevance
Price: low to high
Price: high to low
Number of reviews
240 houses
Responds fast! avg. 39 minutes
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$287
“Would like to return” though we just stayed one night--it was memorable. cabin was clean, well stocked--hot tub was fab
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$109
“Exactly as it looks in the add” Clean, professional, well appointed. Only downside was the open door on the covered porch that allowed the children next door to spy on us in the hot tub, and the relative closeness of the other cabins - could hear the children next door yelling when we were inside.
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$109
“Clean and Cozy” We really enjoyed our stay. The cabin was simply and efficiently equipped for a lovely weekend! Conveniently located in close proximity to the main park attractions/trail heads.
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$109
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$577
“Nice, clean, good value for two couples” Wife & I stayed one night with another couple. The ladies liked it a lot. Tired from hiking all day so no grave concerns about privacy, which may be an issue for some - but not an issue as regards neighboring a-frames. The upstairs bedroom is open and situated above the downstairs bedroom. 1 bath shared by all. Nice "living room" with fireplace and well-equipped kitchen (corkscrew, stemware, etc.). Used Hot tub / jacuzzi and it was fine.
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$109
Responds fast! avg. 2 hours 30 minutes
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$75
Lakefront cottage near Geneva on the Lake-is-Good
Geneva on the Lake house
1 bedroom / 1 bathroom / sleeps 5
“Awesome!!” Betty and Mike the owners were so great!! We came in for a family reunion, the cottage was awesome, perfectly clean and had everything we needed. The grounds were amazing with a beautiful view, firepit, lots of seating and an arbor that was perfect for my boyfriend to purpose!!! We will be back!!
Responds fast! avg. 50 minutes
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$115
“Great place to stay with some issues though” My wife and I stayed for two nights to celebrate our anniversary. The cabin was great and pretty clean except that the sofa looked dirty. It seemed never being washed for years. The hot tub was nice except that the water had in-balanced PH that led to itchiness of our skin. They should test it before we check in. The problem was resolved after we talked to the maintenance guy. In addition, we suggest to place a small stool besides the hot tub, it would be difficult for short people to climb in. Overall, we liked the place that is within a couple of hour drive from where we live, great for getaway on long weekend.
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$109
OPEN YEAR ROUND! 2BR Lakeview Home Steps to Marina
Lakeview house
2 bedrooms / 1 bathroom / sleeps 8
Responds fast! avg. 58 minutes
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$126
“Clean & comfortable” Clean, comfortable lodgings located a mere 5 minutes from Old Man's Cave.
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$109
“great stay!” Everything was wonderful...clean, comfortable, quiet...it was great!
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$109
Fun 3 BR 2 BA Home in the Island Club - Sleeps 8 - Renovated Outdoor Patio
Put in Bay house
3 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms / sleeps 8
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$90
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$516
Lots of Room to Spread Out in this 3 BR Vacation Home at the Island Club
Put in Bay house
3 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms / sleeps 8
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$90
Large Cleveland Home w/ Fire Pit, Backyard & Bar!
Brook Park house
3 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms / sleeps 10
Responds fast! avg. 58 minutes
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$218
“Awesome Cabin!” My boyfriend and I have stayed in a-frame #1 two years in a row now and we are about to reserve it for a coulpe more nights in March this year. I would recommend any Old Man's Cave Chalet to anyone. The staff is always extremely nice and helpful and the cabins are very clean. We love a-frame #1 because it sits at the top of the hill and it is very private.
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$119
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$149
“Nice, quiet, but” Comfortable and though other a-Frames were near, the back porches were constructed to give a secluded feeling. Scenery on site was beautiful with great views and easy access to Old Man's Cave. Service was friendly and accomodating. Only 2 compliants: 1. The unit must have been vacant for several days and was warm inside and the fridge was not cool at all. We could not use the fridge to store the food we brought, we used our ice chest instead. However, the staff was very responsive and provided a new fridge, which cooled but took several hours to get coole enough for good storage. 2. For the price of the unit, one would expect a few more amenities: Daily Coffee Packets & Tea Packets, Popcorn, etc, items that are often provided at vacation rentals. Overall beautiful scenery, nice and comfortable unit, and friendly and responsive staff.
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$109
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$230
Responds fast! avg. 1 hour 6 minutes
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$148
Fun Group Villa with 3 Bedrooms and 2 Baths in the Island Club - Sleeps 10
Put in Bay house
3 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms / sleeps 10
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$100
New Construction. A Weekend Favorite. 3 BR Home in the Island Club, Sleeps 8
Put in Bay house
3 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms / sleeps 8
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$90
Price per night from
$112
Cozy and Fun! 3 BR 2 BA Island Club Cottage - Sleeps 8, Close to Entrance
Put in Bay house
3 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms / sleeps 8
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$125
Erie Lakefront Condo w/ Views/Beach/Pool/Hot Tub
Port Clinton house
2 bedrooms / 1 bathroom / sleeps 4
Responds fast! avg. 1 hour 50 minutes
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$132
Great Family Vacation Spot! Quiet, Comfortable, Spacious. 3 BR for up to 8
Put in Bay house
3 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms / sleeps 8
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$125
Completely Remodeled. Very Clean Island Club House - 3 BR 2 BA, by the Pool
Put in Bay house
3 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms / sleeps 8
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$90
Want a Great Vacation? Rent This 3 BR 2 BA Home at Island Club - Sleeps 8
Put in Bay house
3 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms / sleeps 8
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$125
“Our 32 yr. anniversay...” It was perfect...from the moment we arrived, the ease of signing in...the weather gave us warmth, the chilly rainy, and there is nothing more soothing than the sound of rain on the roof with the warm glow of a fire. But the biggest treat was the ability to have side by side massages therapists work our tired, over workded and aging bodies the TLC they needed. Blue Valley should be touted and commended! What a blessed event that was. Thankyou so very much! Rick and Linda Waters
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$109
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$344
Great for Groups of 8! Full Deck and Grill. 3 BR 2 BA Home in Island Club
Put in Bay house
3 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms / sleeps 8
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$90
Bring 10 People and Enjoy a 3 BR 2 BA Island Club Home at Put-in-Bay Ohio
Put in Bay house
3 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms / sleeps 10
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$150
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$189
Responds fast! avg. 1 hour 2 minutes
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$171
Spacious Vacation Home on Put-in-Bay that Sleeps 16 w/ 5 BR, 2 BA. Big Pool.
Put in Bay house
5 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms / sleeps 16
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$100
Popular 3 BR 2 BA Home by the Pool in the Island Club Community - Sleeps 8
Put in Bay house
3 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms / sleeps 8
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$90
Charming Historical home minutes to MetroHealth/Downtown Cleveland
Brooklyn house
4 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms / sleeps 5
Match: Rental types
All filters matchPrice per night from
$116