Bay Shore Rentals

Close

Enter dates for more accurate prices

Payment Protection
Your payment for this rental is protected when you pay through FlipKey. Learn more

47 Houses

25

Luxury Yacht Fire Island, Hamptons

Long Island / Bay Shore

Bay Shore yacht

3 6 2 nights min

  • 3 bedrooms
  • sleeps 6
  • 2 nights min
  • Child Friendly

Price per night from

$202

Responds fast!
avg. 1 hour 32 minutes

Price per night from

$202

Great rentals within 20 miles that match your search

Distance approx 13.52 km from Bay Shore

27

"Above the Bay" - Suite-Bedrm ,Den,Bath & Kitchen

Long Island / East Patchogue

East Patchogue apartment

1 2 3 nights min

  • 1 bedroom
  • sleeps 2
  • 3 nights min
  • Air conditioning
  • Private garden

Price per night from

$166

Price per night from

$166

Distance approx 6.96 km from Bay Shore Show on Map

19

Charming Bay View Cottage

Fire Island / Ocean Beach

Ocean Beach cottage

2 5 6 nights min

  • 2 bedrooms
  • sleeps 5
  • 6 nights min
  • Child Friendly
  • Pet Friendly

Price per night from

$489

Price per night from

$489

Distance approx 7.72 km from Bay Shore Show on Map

31

Rent entire house with 6 bedrooms

Long Island / West Babylon

West Babylon house

6 14 1 night min

  • 6 bedrooms
  • sleeps 14
  • 1 night min
  • Child Friendly
  • Air conditioning
  • Private garden

Price per night from

$171

Responds fast!
avg. 1 hour 7 minutes

Price per night from

$171

Distance approx 18.21 km from Bay Shore

51

Frank Lloyd Wright Prairie Style Home on 4 Acres Wild Life Refuge

Long Island / Brookhaven

Brookhaven house

5 15 3 nights min

  • 5 bedrooms
  • sleeps 15
  • 3 nights min
  • Child Friendly
  • Air conditioning
  • Pet Friendly

Price per night from

$569

Responds fast!
avg. 1 hour 46 minutes

Price per night from

$569

Distance approx 5.57 km from Bay Shore Show on Map

(1) Excellent 

20

Beautiful Relaxing Sun Room

Long Island / West Babylon

West Babylon house

1 4 1 night min

  • 1 bedroom
  • sleeps 4
  • 1 night min

Price per night from

$92

Price per night from

$92

Distance approx 18.31 km from Bay Shore

(1) Excellent 

9

Central Location to Long Island Attractions

Long Island / Coram

Coram house

2 4 4 nights min

  • 2 bedrooms
  • sleeps 4
  • 4 nights min
  • Air conditioning
  • Private garden

Price per night from

$144

Price per night from

$144

Distance approx 6.69 km from Bay Shore Show on Map

(1) Very Good 

16

Fair Harbor, Fire Island,NY 3 brdrooms plus an open loft. paradise near the bay

Fire Island / Fair Harbor

Fair Harbor house

4 7 3 nights min

  • 4 bedrooms
  • sleeps 7
  • 3 nights min
  • Beach / lakeside relaxation
  • Nearest beach 0.16 mi
  • Child Friendly

Price per night from

$859

Price per night from

$859

Distance approx 9.46 km from Bay Shore

(1) Excellent 

23

Cherry Grove Oceanfront with Heated Pool

Fire Island / Cherry Grove

Cherry Grove house

1 4 7 nights min

  • 1 bedroom
  • sleeps 4
  • 7 nights min
  • Beach / lakeside relaxation
  • Swimming pool
  • Car not necessary

Price per night from

$575

Price per night from

$575

Distance approx 17.05 km from Bay Shore

12

Beautiful Waterfront Home with private beach

Long Island / East Setauket

East Setauket house

5 10 21 nights min

  • 5 bedrooms
  • sleeps 10
  • 21 nights min
  • Beach / lakeside relaxation
  • Nearest beach 2 mi
  • Child Friendly

Price per night from

$1,134

Price per night from

$1,134

Distance approx 6.99 km from Bay Shore Show on Map

(3) Average 

33

Blue Parrot 3 Bedroom, 1 bath, large deck, wi-fi, sat TV, d/w, microwave

Fire Island / Ocean Beach

Ocean Beach apartment

3 8 3 nights min

  • 3 bedrooms
  • sleeps 8
  • 3 nights min
  • Nearest beach 0.2 mi
  • Child Friendly
  • Car not necessary

Price per night from

$345

Responds fast!
avg. 1 hour 23 minutes

Price per night from

$345

Distance approx 7.22 km from Bay Shore Show on Map

8

Summer 2019 - steps from the ocean

Fire Island / Ocean Beach

Ocean Beach house

4 8 min stay varies

  • 4 bedrooms
  • sleeps 8
  • min stay varies
  • Child Friendly
  • Car not necessary
  • Pet Friendly

Price per night from

$661

Price per night from

$661

Distance approx 11.19 km from Bay Shore

(4) Excellent 

16

Ground floor sunlit apt. in great area!

Long Island / Huntington

Huntington apartment

1 4 1 night min

  • 1 bedroom
  • sleeps 4
  • 1 night min
  • Swimming pool
  • Ask about children
  • Ask about pets

Price per night from

$98

Responds fast!
avg. 3 hours 8 minutes

Price per night from

$98

Distance approx 18.94 km from Bay Shore

(1) Excellent 

7

Comfort Retreat

Long Island / Hempstead

Hempstead studio

Studio 4 1 night min

  • Studio
  • sleeps 4
  • 1 night min
  • Child Friendly
  • Air conditioning
  • Private garden

Price per night from

$69

Price per night from

$69

Distance approx 15.08 km from Bay Shore

(4) Excellent 

9

Spectacular waterfront furnished one bedroom

Long Island / Bellmore

Bellmore apartment

1 4 2 nights min

  • 1 bedroom
  • sleeps 4
  • 2 nights min
  • Beach / lakeside relaxation
  • Nearest beach 10 mi
  • Ask about children

Price per night from

$126

Responds fast!
avg. 45 minutes

Price per night from

$126

Distance approx 6.74 km from Bay Shore Show on Map

5

Fire Island - Kismet, Steps from the Ocean

Fire Island / Kismet

Kismet apartment

1 4 2 nights min

  • 1 bedroom
  • sleeps 4
  • 2 nights min
  • Child Friendly
  • Car not necessary
  • Air conditioning

Price per night from

$287

Price per night from

$287

Distance approx 1.56 km from Bay Shore Show on Map

24

Modern Islip Apt near Main St! & Fire Island Ferry

Long Island / Islip

Islip apartment

2 6 min stay varies

  • 2 bedrooms
  • sleeps 6
  • min stay varies
  • Child Friendly
  • Air conditioning
  • Pet Friendly

Price per night from

$156

Responds fast!
avg. 14 minutes

Price per night from

$156

Distance approx 6.65 km from Bay Shore Show on Map

(7) Excellent 

25

Adorable home with Large PRIVATE deck- Fire Island

Fire Island / Kismet

Kismet house

4 8 7 nights min

  • 4 bedrooms
  • sleeps 8
  • 7 nights min
  • Beach / lakeside relaxation
  • Nearest beach 0.16 mi
  • Child Friendly

Price per night from

$573

Responds fast!
avg. 3 hours 37 minutes

Price per night from

$573

Distance approx 6.99 km from Bay Shore Show on Map

(1) Very Good 

24

Fire Island Home-Deck, Grill & Stunning Bay Views!

Long Island / Fire Island

Fire Island house

4 12 min stay varies

  • 4 bedrooms
  • sleeps 12
  • min stay varies
  • Child Friendly
  • Air conditioning

Price per night from

$573

Responds fast!
avg. 26 minutes

Price per night from

$573

Distance approx 7.04 km from Bay Shore Show on Map

9

Great Family Rental - Sun Sand and Surf!

Fire Island / Ocean Beach

Ocean Beach house

4 10 6 nights min

  • 4 bedrooms
  • sleeps 10
  • 6 nights min
  • Air conditioning
  • Pet Friendly

Price per night from

$978

Responds fast!
avg. 9 minutes

Price per night from

$978

Distance approx 19.73 km from Bay Shore

12

2-Bedroom Apartment in Private Home - In Upscale Area - Quiet & Peaceful Getaway

Long Island / Baldwin

Baldwin apartment

2 6 3 nights min

  • 2 bedrooms
  • sleeps 6
  • 3 nights min
  • Child Friendly
  • Air conditioning
  • Private garden

Price per night from

$156

Responds fast!
avg. 3 hours 2 minutes

Price per night from

$156

Distance approx 19.18 km from Bay Shore

17

Private 2nd floor apartment

Long Island / Carle Place

Carle Place apartment

1 4 2 nights min

  • 1 bedroom
  • sleeps 4
  • 2 nights min
  • Nearest beach 12 mi
  • Child Friendly
  • Air conditioning

Price per night from

$81

Price per night from

$81

Distance approx 19.55 km from Bay Shore

4

Beautiful 2 bedroom apartment very cozy and comfortable with unlimited parking..

Long Island / Middle Island

Middle Island apartment

2 6 1 night min

  • 2 bedrooms
  • sleeps 6
  • 1 night min
  • Child Friendly
  • Air conditioning
  • Pet Friendly

Price per night from

$184

Price per night from

$184

Distance approx 1.56 km from Bay Shore Show on Map

25

Charming Islip Apt - Minutes to Main St & Ferry!

Long Island / Islip

Islip apartment

2 4 min stay varies

  • 2 bedrooms
  • sleeps 4
  • min stay varies
  • Child Friendly
  • Air conditioning
  • Pet Friendly

Price per night from

$173

Responds fast!
avg. 26 minutes

Price per night from

$173

Distance approx 13.78 km from Bay Shore

6

Cheaper Than a Hotel! Spacious Guest Suite in Medford, Long Island

Long Island / Medford

Medford room

1 2 1 night min

  • 1 bedroom
  • sleeps 2
  • 1 night min
  • Child Friendly
  • Air conditioning
  • Pet Friendly

Price per night from

$104

Price per night from

$104

Distance approx 7.28 km from Bay Shore Show on Map

14

Charming Fire Island House (Seaview) - Private Deck - Family Friendly

Long Island / Fire Island

Fire Island house

3 8 6 nights min

  • 3 bedrooms
  • sleeps 8
  • 6 nights min
  • Child Friendly
  • Pet Friendly
  • Private garden

Price per night from

$862

Price per night from

$862

Distance approx 13.51 km from Bay Shore

16

Charming Room - Private Entrance

Long Island / Levittown

Levittown room

1 4 30 nights min

  • 1 bedroom
  • sleeps 4
  • 30 nights min
  • Nearest beach 19 mi
  • Child Friendly
  • Air conditioning

Price per night from

$57

Responds fast!
avg. 2 hours 47 minutes

Price per night from

$57

Distance approx 9.4 km from Bay Shore

23

Great 2 Bedroom Oceanfront House

Fire Island / Cherry Grove

Cherry Grove house

2 4 7 nights min

  • 2 bedrooms
  • sleeps 4
  • 7 nights min
  • Beach / lakeside relaxation
  • Nearest beach 0 mi
  • Ask about children

Price per night from

$460

Price per night from

$460

Distance approx 16.19 km from Bay Shore

24

NEW! Charming 2BR Bellport Cottage - 5 Min to Bay!

Long Island / Bellport

Bellport cottage

2 6 min stay varies

  • 2 bedrooms
  • sleeps 6
  • min stay varies
  • Suitable for children age 5+
  • Air conditioning
  • Pet Friendly

Price per night from

$201

Responds fast!
avg. 26 minutes

Price per night from

$201

Distance approx 7.15 km from Bay Shore Show on Map

12

Fire island beach house

Fire Island / Ocean Beach

Ocean Beach house

4 10 7 nights min

  • 4 bedrooms
  • sleeps 10
  • 7 nights min
  • Child Friendly
  • Pet Friendly

Price per night from

$904

Price per night from

$904

Distance approx 7.64 km from Bay Shore Show on Map

9

Sunny Ocean Bay Park (Fire Island) Beach Apartment - Short walk to beach.

Fire Island / Ocean Bay Park

Ocean Bay Park apartment

3 6 4 nights min

  • 3 bedrooms
  • sleeps 6
  • 4 nights min
  • Child Friendly

Price per night from

$661

Price per night from

$661

Distance approx 7.06 km from Bay Shore Show on Map

4

Mermaid House

Fire Island / Ocean Beach

Ocean Beach house

4 10 2 nights min

  • 4 bedrooms
  • sleeps 10
  • 2 nights min
  • Child Friendly
  • Air conditioning
  • Private garden

Price per night from

$481

Price per night from

$481

Distance approx 18.65 km from Bay Shore

43

Centre Island Estate

Long Island / Oyster Bay

Oyster Bay house

6 50 min stay varies

  • 6 bedrooms
  • sleeps 50
  • min stay varies
  • Nearest beach 1 mi
  • Swimming pool
  • Child Friendly

Price per night from

$1,145

Price per night from

$1,145

Distance approx 7.26 km from Bay Shore Show on Map

19

COOL SUMMER BEACH HOUSE

Fire Island / Ocean Beach

Ocean Beach house

5 10 min stay varies

  • 5 bedrooms
  • sleeps 10
  • min stay varies
  • Child Friendly
  • Air conditioning
  • Private garden

Price per night from

$920

Price per night from

$920

Distance approx 6.81 km from Bay Shore Show on Map

21

Fire Island Cottage-3Bed2Bath

Fire Island / Fair Harbor

Fair Harbor cottage

3 6 6 nights min

  • 3 bedrooms
  • sleeps 6
  • 6 nights min
  • Beach / lakeside relaxation
  • Nearest beach 0.1 mi
  • Child Friendly

Price per night from

$977

Price per night from

$977

Distance approx 6.77 km from Bay Shore Show on Map

14

Fire Island New York - 3 Bed

Long Island / Fire Island

Fire Island cottage

3 6 30 nights min

  • 3 bedrooms
  • sleeps 6
  • 30 nights min
  • Beach / lakeside relaxation
  • Suitable for children age 5+
  • Car not necessary

Price per night from

$756

Price per night from

$756

Distance approx 19.52 km from Bay Shore

35

Nelly home

Long Island / Mastic Beach

Mastic Beach house

2 4 1 night min

  • 2 bedrooms
  • sleeps 4
  • 1 night min
  • Nearest beach 0 mi
  • Child Friendly

Price per night from

$345

Price per night from

$345

Distance approx 18.08 km from Bay Shore

24

NEW! Hip Freeport Home by Nautical Mile, JFK+Beach

Long Island / Freeport

Freeport house

2 3 min stay varies

  • 2 bedrooms
  • sleeps 3
  • min stay varies
  • Child Friendly
  • Air conditioning

Price per night from

$138

Responds fast!
avg. 14 minutes

Price per night from

$138