Enter dates for more accurate prices
40 Houses
Oceanfront Luxury Retreat
Fire Island / Ocean Bay Park
5 12 3 nights min
- 5 bedrooms
- sleeps 12
- 3 nights min
- Child Friendly
Map
Price per night from
$2,290
Price per night from
$2,290
Sunny Ocean Bay Park (Fire Island) Beach Apartment - Short walk to beach.
Fire Island / Ocean Bay Park
3 6 4 nights min
- 3 bedrooms
- sleeps 6
- 4 nights min
- Child Friendly
Map
Price per night from
$575
Price per night from
$575
Great rentals within 20 miles that match your search
Distance approx 11.01 km from Ocean Bay Park
Beautiful Relaxing Sun Room
Long Island / West Babylon
1 4 1 night min
- 1 bedroom
- sleeps 4
- 1 night min
Price per night from
$92
Price per night from
$92
Distance approx 10.69 km from Ocean Bay Park
"Above the Bay" - Suite-Bedrm ,Den,Bath & Kitchen
Long Island / East Patchogue
1 2 3 nights min
- 1 bedroom
- sleeps 2
- 3 nights min
- Air conditioning
- Private garden
Price per night from
$166
Price per night from
$166
Distance approx 16.45 km from Ocean Bay Park
Perfect summer haven, ten minutes walk to village
Long Island / Bellport
3 10 4 nights min
- 3 bedrooms
- sleeps 10
- 4 nights min
- Swimming pool
- Child Friendly
- Air conditioning
Price per night from
$400
Price per night from
$400
Distance approx 14.09 km from Ocean Bay Park
Rent entire house with 6 bedrooms
Long Island / West Babylon
6 14 1 night min
- 6 bedrooms
- sleeps 14
- 1 night min
- Child Friendly
- Air conditioning
- Private garden
Price per night from
$149
Responds fast!
avg. 1 hour 7 minutes
Price per night from
$149
Distance approx 0.1 km from Ocean Bay Park Show on Map
NEW! Cozy Fire Island Studio - Steps to the Beach!
Fire Island / Ocean Beach
Studio 2 min stay varies
- Studio
- sleeps 2
- min stay varies
- Child Friendly
- Air conditioning
Map
Price per night from
$115
Responds fast!
avg. 10 minutes
Price per night from
$115
Distance approx 1.01 km from Ocean Bay Park Show on Map
Charming Bay View Cottage
Fire Island / Ocean Beach
2 5 6 nights min
- 2 bedrooms
- sleeps 5
- 6 nights min
- Child Friendly
- Pet Friendly
Map
Price per night from
$487
Price per night from
$487
Distance approx 15.66 km from Ocean Bay Park
Frank Lloyd Wright Prairie Style Home on 4 Acres Wild Life Refuge
Long Island / Brookhaven
5 15 3 nights min
- 5 bedrooms
- sleeps 15
- 3 nights min
- Child Friendly
- Air conditioning
- Pet Friendly
Price per night from
$567
Responds fast!
avg. 1 hour 46 minutes
Price per night from
$567
Distance approx 2.1 km from Ocean Bay Park Show on Map
Fire Island Home Across the Street from the Beach!
Long Island / Fire Island
4 8 min stay varies
- 4 bedrooms
- sleeps 8
- min stay varies
- Child Friendly
- Pet Friendly
Map
Price per night from
$450
Responds fast!
avg. 10 minutes
Price per night from
$450
Distance approx 2.87 km from Ocean Bay Park Show on Map
Cherry Grove Oceanfront with Heated Pool
Fire Island / Cherry Grove
1 4 7 nights min
- 1 bedroom
- sleeps 4
- 7 nights min
- Beach / lakeside relaxation
- Swimming pool
- Car not necessary
Map
Price per night from
$500
Price per night from
$500
Distance approx 7.56 km from Ocean Bay Park Show on Map
Luxury Yacht Fire Island, Hamptons
Long Island / Bay Shore
3 6 2 nights min
- 3 bedrooms
- sleeps 6
- 2 nights min
- Child Friendly
Map
Price per night from
$201
Responds fast!
avg. 1 hour 32 minutes
Price per night from
$201
Distance approx 19.27 km from Ocean Bay Park
Central Location to Long Island Attractions
Long Island / Coram
2 4 4 nights min
- 2 bedrooms
- sleeps 4
- 4 nights min
- Air conditioning
- Private garden
Price per night from
$125
Price per night from
$125
Distance approx 2.52 km from Ocean Bay Park Show on Map
Fair Harbor, Fire Island,NY 3 brdrooms plus an open loft. paradise near the bay
Fire Island / Fair Harbor
4 7 3 nights min
- 4 bedrooms
- sleeps 7
- 3 nights min
- Beach / lakeside relaxation
- Nearest beach 0.16 mi
- Child Friendly
Map
Price per night from
$859
Price per night from
$859
Distance approx 1.08 km from Ocean Bay Park Show on Map
Summer 2019 - steps from the ocean
Fire Island / Ocean Beach
4 8 min stay varies
- 4 bedrooms
- sleeps 8
- min stay varies
- Child Friendly
- Car not necessary
- Pet Friendly
Map
Price per night from
$575
Price per night from
$575
Distance approx 7.22 km from Ocean Bay Park Show on Map
Modern Islip Apt near Main St! & Fire Island Ferry
Long Island / Islip
2 6 min stay varies
- 2 bedrooms
- sleeps 6
- min stay varies
- Child Friendly
- Air conditioning
- Pet Friendly
Map
Price per night from
$155
Responds fast!
avg. 14 minutes
Price per night from
$155
Distance approx 3.46 km from Ocean Bay Park Show on Map
Fire Island - Kismet, Steps from the Ocean
Fire Island / Kismet
1 4 2 nights min
- 1 bedroom
- sleeps 4
- 2 nights min
- Child Friendly
- Car not necessary
- Air conditioning
Map
Price per night from
$287
Price per night from
$287
Distance approx 0.1 km from Ocean Bay Park Show on Map
Blue Parrot 3 Bedroom, 1 bath, large deck, wi-fi, sat TV, d/w, microwave
Fire Island / Ocean Beach
3 8 3 nights min
- 3 bedrooms
- sleeps 8
- 3 nights min
- Nearest beach 0.2 mi
- Child Friendly
- Car not necessary
Map
Price per night from
$300
Responds fast!
avg. 1 hour 23 minutes
Price per night from
$300
Distance approx 18.79 km from Ocean Bay Park
Ground floor sunlit apt. in great area!
Long Island / Huntington
1 4 1 night min
- 1 bedroom
- sleeps 4
- 1 night min
- Swimming pool
- Ask about children
- Ask about pets
Price per night from
$85
Responds fast!
avg. 3 hours 8 minutes
Price per night from
$85
Distance approx 3.43 km from Ocean Bay Park Show on Map
Adorable home with Large PRIVATE deck- Fire Island
Fire Island / Kismet
4 8 7 nights min
- 4 bedrooms
- sleeps 8
- 7 nights min
- Beach / lakeside relaxation
- Nearest beach 0.16 mi
- Child Friendly
Map
Price per night from
$500
Responds fast!
avg. 3 hours 37 minutes
Price per night from
$500
Distance approx 1.35 km from Ocean Bay Park Show on Map
Fire Island Home-Deck, Grill & Stunning Bay Views!
Long Island / Fire Island
4 12 min stay varies
- 4 bedrooms
- sleeps 12
- min stay varies
- Child Friendly
- Air conditioning
Map
Price per night from
$500
Price per night from
$500
Distance approx 19.54 km from Ocean Bay Park
Beautiful 2 bedroom apartment very cozy and comfortable with unlimited parking..
Long Island / Middle Island
2 6 1 night min
- 2 bedrooms
- sleeps 6
- 1 night min
- Child Friendly
- Air conditioning
- Pet Friendly
Price per night from
$184
Price per night from
$184
Distance approx 0.1 km from Ocean Bay Park Show on Map
Great Family Rental - Sun Sand and Surf!
Fire Island / Ocean Beach
4 10 6 nights min
- 4 bedrooms
- sleeps 10
- 6 nights min
- Air conditioning
- Pet Friendly
Map
Price per night from
$974
Responds fast!
avg. 9 minutes
Price per night from
$974
Distance approx 0.1 km from Ocean Bay Park Show on Map
Charming Fire Island House (Seaview) - Private Deck - Family Friendly
Long Island / Fire Island
3 8 6 nights min
- 3 bedrooms
- sleeps 8
- 6 nights min
- Child Friendly
- Pet Friendly
- Private garden
Map
Price per night from
$859
Price per night from
$859
Distance approx 7.22 km from Ocean Bay Park Show on Map
Charming Islip Apt - Minutes to Main St & Ferry!
Long Island / Islip
2 4 min stay varies
- 2 bedrooms
- sleeps 4
- min stay varies
- Child Friendly
- Air conditioning
- Pet Friendly
Map
Price per night from
$150
Responds fast!
avg. 10 minutes
Price per night from
$150
Distance approx 0.1 km from Ocean Bay Park Show on Map
NEW! Ocean Beach Home w/Outdoor Shower & Deck!
Fire Island / Ocean Beach
3 6 6 nights min
- 3 bedrooms
- sleeps 6
- 6 nights min
- Child Friendly
- Air conditioning
- Pet Friendly
Map
Price per night from
$630
Responds fast!
avg. 14 minutes
Price per night from
$630
Distance approx 7.22 km from Ocean Bay Park Show on Map
NEW! Islip Condo Near Main St & Fire Island Ferry!
Long Island / Islip
1 4 min stay varies
- 1 bedroom
- sleeps 4
- min stay varies
- Child Friendly
- Air conditioning
Map
Price per night from
$189
Responds fast!
avg. 14 minutes
Price per night from
$189
Distance approx 12.6 km from Ocean Bay Park
Cheaper Than a Hotel! Spacious Guest Suite in Medford, Long Island
Long Island / Medford
1 2 1 night min
- 1 bedroom
- sleeps 2
- 1 night min
- Child Friendly
- Air conditioning
- Pet Friendly
Price per night from
$90
Price per night from
$90
Distance approx 2.87 km from Ocean Bay Park Show on Map
Great 2 Bedroom Oceanfront House
Fire Island / Cherry Grove
2 4 7 nights min
- 2 bedrooms
- sleeps 4
- 7 nights min
- Beach / lakeside relaxation
- Nearest beach 0 mi
- Ask about children
Map
Price per night from
$400
Price per night from
$400
Distance approx 13.12 km from Ocean Bay Park
NEW! Charming 2BR Bellport Cottage - 5 Min to Bay!
Long Island / Bellport
2 6 min stay varies
- 2 bedrooms
- sleeps 6
- min stay varies
- Suitable for children age 5+
- Air conditioning
- Pet Friendly
Price per night from
$201
Responds fast!
avg. 14 minutes
Price per night from
$201
Distance approx 7.22 km from Ocean Bay Park Show on Map
Islip Apartment Near Beach And Fire Island Ferry!
Long Island / Islip
1 4 min stay varies
- 1 bedroom
- sleeps 4
- min stay varies
- Child Friendly
- Air conditioning
- Pet Friendly
Map
Price per night from
$150
Responds fast!
avg. 10 minutes
Price per night from
$150
Distance approx 0.1 km from Ocean Bay Park Show on Map
Fire island beach house
Fire Island / Ocean Beach
4 10 7 nights min
- 4 bedrooms
- sleeps 10
- 7 nights min
- Child Friendly
- Pet Friendly
Map
Price per night from
$786
Price per night from
$786
Distance approx 0.1 km from Ocean Bay Park Show on Map
Mermaid House
Fire Island / Ocean Beach
4 10 2 nights min
- 4 bedrooms
- sleeps 10
- 2 nights min
- Child Friendly
- Air conditioning
- Private garden
Map
Price per night from
$481
Price per night from
$481
Distance approx 0.1 km from Ocean Bay Park Show on Map
COOL SUMMER BEACH HOUSE
Fire Island / Ocean Beach
5 10 min stay varies
- 5 bedrooms
- sleeps 10
- min stay varies
- Child Friendly
- Air conditioning
- Private garden
Map
Price per night from
$800
Price per night from
$800
Distance approx 2.07 km from Ocean Bay Park Show on Map
Fire Island Cottage-3Bed2Bath
Fire Island / Fair Harbor
3 6 6 nights min
- 3 bedrooms
- sleeps 6
- 6 nights min
- Beach / lakeside relaxation
- Nearest beach 0.1 mi
- Child Friendly
Map
Price per night from
$850
Price per night from
$850
Distance approx 2.06 km from Ocean Bay Park Show on Map
Fire Island New York - 3 Bed
Long Island / Fire Island
3 6 30 nights min
- 3 bedrooms
- sleeps 6
- 30 nights min
- Beach / lakeside relaxation
- Suitable for children age 5+
- Car not necessary
Map
Price per night from
$657
Price per night from
$657
Distance approx 15.67 km from Ocean Bay Park
Nelly home
Long Island / Mastic Beach
2 4 1 night min
- 2 bedrooms
- sleeps 4
- 1 night min
- Nearest beach 0 mi
- Child Friendly
Price per night from
$300
Price per night from
$300
Distance approx 11.89 km from Ocean Bay Park
Studio + Your Own Bar & FREE Splish Splash Tickets
Long Island / Brentwood
Studio 2 1 night min
- Studio
- sleeps 2
- 1 night min
Price per night from
$99
Price per night from
$99
What is Certificate of Excellence?
TripAdvisor gives a Certificate of Excellence to accommodations, attractions and restaurants that consistently earn great reviews from travelers.