Penn Yan Rentals

Close

Enter dates for more accurate prices

Payment Protection
Your payment for this rental is protected when you pay through FlipKey. Learn more

95 Houses

(2) Excellent 

    22

    Historic Stone Farmhouse Recently Renovated

    Finger Lakes / Penn Yan

    Penn Yan house

    3 5 2 nights min

    • 3 bedrooms
    • sleeps 5
    • 2 nights min
    • Child Friendly
    • Air conditioning
    • Private garden

    Price per night from

    $338

    Price per night from

    $338

      12

      Seneca Lake Waterfront, Central to Wine Trail - Sleeps 6

      Finger Lakes / Penn Yan

      Penn Yan cottage

      3 6 2 nights min

      • 3 bedrooms
      • sleeps 6
      • 2 nights min
      • Child Friendly
      • Air conditioning
      • Pet Friendly

      Price per night from

      $286

      Responds fast!
      avg. 2 hours 56 minutes

      Price per night from

      $286

      (3) Very Good 

        25

        BOOK NOW FOR 2018.......HWS COLLEGE GRAD WEEKEND AND MEMORIAL DAY WEEKEND OPEN

        Finger Lakes / Penn Yan

        Penn Yan house

        4 8 3 nights min

        • 4 bedrooms
        • sleeps 8
        • 3 nights min
        • Beach / lakeside relaxation
        • Child Friendly
        • Private garden

        Price per night from

        $458

        Price per night from

        $458

        (1) Excellent 

          26

          Whispering Waters, a cozy lakefront home-away-from-home!

          Finger Lakes / Penn Yan

          Penn Yan house

          3 10 min stay varies

          • 3 bedrooms
          • sleeps 10
          • min stay varies
          • Child Friendly
          • Air conditioning
          • Private garden

          Price per night from

          $229

          Price per night from

          $229

          Great rentals within 20 miles that match your search

          Distance approx 12.83 km from Penn Yan

            31

            It's A Grape Place: Keuka Renters Paradise

            Finger Lakes / Wayne

            Wayne house

            5 14 1 night min

            • 5 bedrooms
            • sleeps 14
            • 1 night min
            • Child Friendly

            Price per night from

            $343

            Price per night from

            $343

            Distance approx 18.75 km from Penn Yan

              18

              Secluded All-Season Home with Outdoor Cedar Hot Tub, close to Wineries and Lake

              Finger Lakes / Watkins Glen

              Watkins Glen house

              3 8 1 night min

              • 3 bedrooms
              • sleeps 8
              • 1 night min
              • Child Friendly
              • Air conditioning
              • Pet Friendly

              Price per night from

              $372

              Price per night from

              $372

              Distance approx 11.66 km from Penn Yan Show on Map

                24

                Magnolia Lakeside Cottage on Seneca Lake

                Finger Lakes / Romulus

                Romulus cottage

                2 7 6 nights min

                • 2 bedrooms
                • sleeps 7
                • 6 nights min
                • Child Friendly
                • Pet Friendly
                • Private garden

                Price per night from

                $487

                Price per night from

                $487

                Distance approx 19.14 km from Penn Yan

                  32

                  Lizzie's Cabin on the Hill

                  Finger Lakes / Canandaigua

                  Canandaigua house

                  3 8 2 nights min

                  • 3 bedrooms
                  • sleeps 8
                  • 2 nights min
                  • Child Friendly

                  Price per night from

                  $401

                  Responds fast!
                  avg. 3 hours 37 minutes

                  Price per night from

                  $401

                  Distance approx 18.74 km from Penn Yan

                  (2) Very Good 

                    27

                    Private Canandaigua Lake Cottage 200 ft lakefront

                    Finger Lakes / Canandaigua

                    Canandaigua cottage

                    6 10 7 nights min

                    • 6 bedrooms
                    • sleeps 10
                    • 7 nights min
                    • Beach / lakeside relaxation
                    • Child Friendly
                    • Private garden

                    Price per night from

                    $458

                    Price per night from

                    $458

                    Distance approx 15.49 km from Penn Yan

                      10

                      Lakefront home on prestigious Menteth Point - quiet, family-friendly, & tennis

                      Finger Lakes / Canandaigua

                      Canandaigua house

                      3 6 7 nights min

                      • 3 bedrooms
                      • sleeps 6
                      • 7 nights min
                      • Child Friendly
                      • Pet Friendly

                      Price per night from

                      $409

                      Responds fast!
                      avg. 56 minutes

                      Price per night from

                      $409

                      Distance approx 10.64 km from Penn Yan Show on Map

                      (8) Excellent 

                        13

                        Pebble Beach

                        Finger Lakes / Romulus

                        Romulus cottage

                        3 10 2 nights min

                        • 3 bedrooms
                        • sleeps 10
                        • 2 nights min
                        • Child Friendly
                        • Air conditioning
                        • Pet Friendly
                        “Great house right on the lake, lots of sleeping space” Clean, nice home, with lots of beds, good TV, and WiFi right on the lake. Good parking for a few cars too. Owners were prompt to correspond via email.

                        Price per night from

                        $344

                        Responds fast!
                        avg. 2 hours 59 minutes

                        Price per night from

                        $344

                        Distance approx 14.4 km from Penn Yan

                        (27) Excellent 

                        Certificate of Excellence

                          25

                          Spot o' Gold

                          Finger Lakes / Canandaigua

                          Canandaigua cottage

                          3 4 3 nights min

                          • 3 bedrooms
                          • sleeps 4
                          • 3 nights min
                          • Beach / lakeside relaxation
                          • Nearest beach 0.5 mi
                          • Child Friendly
                          “Perfect!” Evie is a wonderful host. She had done a remarkable job with her cottage and garden. She has everything you might need. This is a perfect place for a family gathering or a quiet retreat.

                          Certificate of Excellence

                          Price per night from

                          $201

                          Responds fast!
                          avg. 16 minutes

                          Price per night from

                          $201

                          Distance approx 9.87 km from Penn Yan Show on Map

                          (7) Excellent 

                            13

                            3 bedroom Seneca Lake East Side

                            Finger Lakes / Lodi

                            Lodi cottage

                            3 6 2 nights min

                            • 3 bedrooms
                            • sleeps 6
                            • 2 nights min
                            • Beach / lakeside relaxation
                            • Child Friendly
                            • Air conditioning
                            “Great stay!” Super clean house with great access to the lake! Quiet residential area with nice places to walk and enjoy the views. Saw a beautiful sunset - close proximity to some wonderful wineries! Would love to come back someday!

                            Price per night from

                            $287

                            Price per night from

                            $287

                            Distance approx 17.45 km from Penn Yan

                            (2) Very Good 

                              9

                              Manor House Estate

                              Finger Lakes / Hammondsport

                              Hammondsport manor house

                              5 16 min stay varies

                              • 5 bedrooms
                              • sleeps 16
                              • min stay varies
                              • Beach / lakeside relaxation
                              • Child Friendly
                              • Air conditioning

                              Price per night from

                              $910

                              Responds fast!
                              avg. 3 hours 47 minutes

                              Price per night from

                              $910

                              Distance approx 18.89 km from Penn Yan

                                18

                                Secluded cabin with amenities near Keuka and Seneca Lake

                                Finger Lakes / Hammondsport

                                Hammondsport cottage

                                3 10 2 nights min

                                • 3 bedrooms
                                • sleeps 10
                                • 2 nights min
                                • Child Friendly
                                • Pet Friendly

                                Price per night from

                                $229

                                Price per night from

                                $229

                                Distance approx 14.07 km from Penn Yan

                                  12

                                  Glamping in the Finger Lakes National Forest - pet-friendly w/ breakfast incl!

                                  Finger Lakes / Lodi

                                  Lodi house

                                  2 6 2 nights min

                                  • 2 bedrooms
                                  • sleeps 6
                                  • 2 nights min
                                  • Child Friendly
                                  • Air conditioning
                                  • Pet Friendly

                                  Price per night from

                                  $274

                                  Responds fast!
                                  avg. 10 minutes

                                  Price per night from

                                  $274

                                  Distance approx 4.86 km from Penn Yan Show on Map

                                    20

                                    Flip Flop Inn Cottage 3 Bedrooms

                                    Finger Lakes / Keuka Park

                                    Keuka Park cottage

                                    3 5 min stay varies

                                    • 3 bedrooms
                                    • sleeps 5
                                    • min stay varies
                                    • Child Friendly
                                    • Car not necessary
                                    • Air conditioning

                                    Price per night from

                                    $301

                                    Price per night from

                                    $301

                                    Distance approx 14.91 km from Penn Yan

                                    (1) Excellent 

                                      17

                                      The Lighthouse

                                      Finger Lakes / Middlesex

                                      Middlesex house

                                      4 10 2 nights min

                                      • 4 bedrooms
                                      • sleeps 10
                                      • 2 nights min
                                      • Beach / lakeside relaxation
                                      • Suitable for children age 5+
                                      • Air conditioning

                                      Price per night from

                                      $802

                                      Price per night from

                                      $802

                                      Distance approx 17.13 km from Penn Yan

                                        17

                                        Lakeside Studio with kitchenette +-

                                        Finger Lakes / Canandaigua

                                        Canandaigua apartment

                                        1 4 min stay varies

                                        • 1 bedroom
                                        • sleeps 4
                                        • min stay varies
                                        • Beach / lakeside relaxation
                                        • Nearest beach 0.4 mi
                                        • Child Friendly

                                        Price per night from

                                        $143

                                        Responds fast!
                                        avg. 2 hours 49 minutes

                                        Price per night from

                                        $143

                                        Distance approx 19.34 km from Penn Yan

                                        (3) Excellent 

                                          27

                                          Spacious 2400q house on the East side of the lake

                                          Finger Lakes / Watkins Glen

                                          Watkins Glen house

                                          4 9 3 nights min

                                          • 4 bedrooms
                                          • sleeps 9
                                          • 3 nights min
                                          • Beach / lakeside relaxation
                                          • Child Friendly
                                          • Air conditioning

                                          Price per night from

                                          $435

                                          Price per night from

                                          $435

                                          Distance approx 14.41 km from Penn Yan

                                          (2) Very Good 

                                            20

                                            Serene Cottage in Wine Country with Lake Access

                                            Finger Lakes / Canandaigua

                                            Canandaigua house

                                            2 6 min stay varies

                                            • 2 bedrooms
                                            • sleeps 6
                                            • min stay varies
                                            • Child Friendly
                                            • Private garden

                                            Price per night from

                                            $132

                                            Price per night from

                                            $132

                                            Distance approx 19.27 km from Penn Yan

                                              11

                                              Knoll Top - a little bit of home on the lakes

                                              Finger Lakes / Aurora

                                              Aurora house

                                              3 6 1 night min

                                              • 3 bedrooms
                                              • sleeps 6
                                              • 1 night min
                                              • Child Friendly

                                              Price per night from

                                              $395

                                              Price per night from

                                              $395

                                              Distance approx 11.21 km from Penn Yan

                                              (1) Excellent 

                                                56

                                                Private Keuka Lake-front Chalet | Stunning Views & Game Room Sleeps 10

                                                Starkey / Dundee

                                                Dundee house

                                                3 10 min stay varies

                                                • 3 bedrooms
                                                • sleeps 10
                                                • min stay varies
                                                • Nearest beach 0 mi
                                                • Child Friendly
                                                • Air conditioning

                                                Price per night from

                                                $453

                                                Price per night from

                                                $453

                                                Distance approx 19.01 km from Penn Yan

                                                  22

                                                  Gracious, Spacious Guest House in Village

                                                  Finger Lakes / Aurora

                                                  Aurora house

                                                  5 11 2 nights min

                                                  • 5 bedrooms
                                                  • sleeps 11
                                                  • 2 nights min
                                                  • Beach / lakeside relaxation
                                                  • Child Friendly

                                                  Price per night from

                                                  $1,088

                                                  Price per night from

                                                  $1,088

                                                  Distance approx 12.34 km from Penn Yan Show on Map

                                                    15

                                                    Avant Garde Seneca Cottage 2 Bedrooms

                                                    Finger Lakes / Lakemont

                                                    Lakemont cottage

                                                    2 6 min stay varies

                                                    • 2 bedrooms
                                                    • sleeps 6
                                                    • min stay varies
                                                    • Child Friendly
                                                    • Car not necessary
                                                    • Air conditioning

                                                    Price per night from

                                                    $458

                                                    Price per night from

                                                    $458

                                                    Distance approx 15.3 km from Penn Yan

                                                      30

                                                      Timeless Memories Cottage 6 Bedrooms

                                                      Finger Lakes / Canandaigua

                                                      Canandaigua cottage

                                                      6 14 min stay varies

                                                      • 6 bedrooms
                                                      • sleeps 14
                                                      • min stay varies
                                                      • Child Friendly
                                                      • Car not necessary

                                                      Price per night from

                                                      $1,250

                                                      Price per night from

                                                      $1,250

                                                      Distance approx 14.42 km from Penn Yan

                                                        8

                                                        Canandaigua Lake Getaway

                                                        Finger Lakes / Middlesex

                                                        Middlesex house

                                                        3 5 2 nights min

                                                        • 3 bedrooms
                                                        • sleeps 5
                                                        • 2 nights min
                                                        • Child Friendly
                                                        • Air conditioning

                                                        Price per night from

                                                        $212

                                                        Price per night from

                                                        $212

                                                        Distance approx 9.86 km from Penn Yan Show on Map

                                                        (2) Excellent 

                                                          44

                                                          The Kingfisher Chalet Vacation Rental: Amazing sunsets overlooking Keuka Lake

                                                          Starkey / Dundee

                                                          Dundee house

                                                          4 8 2 nights min

                                                          • 4 bedrooms
                                                          • sleeps 8
                                                          • 2 nights min
                                                          • Child Friendly
                                                          • Air conditioning
                                                          • Private garden

                                                          Price per night from

                                                          $372

                                                          Price per night from

                                                          $372

                                                          Distance approx 14.58 km from Penn Yan

                                                            20

                                                            Precious Moments Cottage 3 Bedrooms

                                                            Finger Lakes / Rushville

                                                            Rushville cottage

                                                            3 7 min stay varies

                                                            • 3 bedrooms
                                                            • sleeps 7
                                                            • min stay varies
                                                            • Child Friendly
                                                            • Car not necessary

                                                            Price per night from

                                                            $276

                                                            Price per night from

                                                            $276

                                                            Distance approx 17.39 km from Penn Yan

                                                              21

                                                              Charming Cottage on Cayuga Lake & Guest Cottage-- Pet Friendly

                                                              Finger Lakes / Romulus

                                                              Romulus cottage

                                                              4 8 min stay varies

                                                              • 4 bedrooms
                                                              • sleeps 8
                                                              • min stay varies
                                                              • Child Friendly
                                                              • Air conditioning
                                                              • Pet Friendly

                                                              Price per night from

                                                              $409

                                                              Responds fast!
                                                              avg. 1 hour 24 minutes

                                                              Price per night from

                                                              $409

                                                              Distance approx 14.07 km from Penn Yan

                                                              (1) Excellent 

                                                                17

                                                                Glamping Cabin in Natl Forest - pet-friendly, fully furnished, hot tub, bkfst!!

                                                                Finger Lakes / Lodi

                                                                Lodi cottage

                                                                2 6 2 nights min

                                                                • 2 bedrooms
                                                                • sleeps 6
                                                                • 2 nights min
                                                                • Child Friendly
                                                                • Air conditioning
                                                                • Pet Friendly

                                                                Price per night from

                                                                $274

                                                                Responds fast!
                                                                avg. 10 minutes

                                                                Price per night from

                                                                $274

                                                                Distance approx 14.07 km from Penn Yan

                                                                (2) Excellent 

                                                                  15

                                                                  Glamping Cabin in the Forest with fenced in yard for dogs, priv hot tub, bkfst

                                                                  Finger Lakes / Lodi

                                                                  Lodi cottage

                                                                  1 4 2 nights min

                                                                  • 1 bedroom
                                                                  • sleeps 4
                                                                  • 2 nights min
                                                                  • Child Friendly
                                                                  • Air conditioning
                                                                  • Pet Friendly

                                                                  Price per night from

                                                                  $274

                                                                  Responds fast!
                                                                  avg. 10 minutes

                                                                  Price per night from

                                                                  $274

                                                                  Distance approx 19.35 km from Penn Yan

                                                                  (47) Excellent 

                                                                    28

                                                                    Cozy Cove Cottage Lakeside on Cayuga Lake

                                                                    Finger Lakes / Cayuga

                                                                    Cayuga cottage

                                                                    2 4 3 nights min

                                                                    • 2 bedrooms
                                                                    • sleeps 4
                                                                    • 3 nights min
                                                                    • Beach / lakeside relaxation
                                                                    • Private garden
                                                                    “Quaint and charming cottage with everything you need” This cottage is much nicer than a typical rental place. It's an older cottage with lots of character but it is very comfortable and it has been preserved with lots of love and attention to detail.

                                                                    Price per night from

                                                                    $269

                                                                    Responds fast!
                                                                    avg. 3 hours 8 minutes

                                                                    Price per night from

                                                                    $269

                                                                    Distance approx 9.82 km from Penn Yan Show on Map

                                                                    (1) Excellent 

                                                                      27

                                                                      Seneca Lake Escape-Stunning Post & Beam

                                                                      Finger Lakes / Romulus

                                                                      Romulus house

                                                                      3 8 min stay varies

                                                                      • 3 bedrooms
                                                                      • sleeps 8
                                                                      • min stay varies
                                                                      • Beach / lakeside relaxation
                                                                      • Ask about children
                                                                      • Air conditioning

                                                                      Price per night from

                                                                      $659

                                                                      Responds fast!
                                                                      avg. 1 hour 3 minutes

                                                                      Price per night from

                                                                      $659

                                                                      Distance approx 12.54 km from Penn Yan

                                                                      (1) Excellent 

                                                                        10

                                                                        Near Wineries, Trails, And Skiing! Woodland Cabin

                                                                        Finger Lakes / Naples

                                                                        Naples log cabin

                                                                        2 5 2 nights min

                                                                        • 2 bedrooms
                                                                        • sleeps 5
                                                                        • 2 nights min
                                                                        • Beach / lakeside relaxation
                                                                        • Child Friendly
                                                                        • Pet Friendly

                                                                        Price per night from

                                                                        $163

                                                                        Price per night from

                                                                        $163

                                                                        Distance approx 16 km from Penn Yan

                                                                          13

                                                                          The Tuscany Room in Villa Bianca Bed & Breakfast

                                                                          Finger Lakes / Canandaigua

                                                                          Canandaigua b and b

                                                                          1 2 1 night min

                                                                          • 1 bedroom
                                                                          • sleeps 2
                                                                          • 1 night min
                                                                          • Child Friendly
                                                                          • Air conditioning

                                                                          Price per night from

                                                                          $212

                                                                          Price per night from

                                                                          $212

                                                                          Distance approx 15.59 km from Penn Yan

                                                                            21

                                                                            Deer View Cottage 3 Bedrooms

                                                                            Finger Lakes / South Bristol

                                                                            South Bristol cottage

                                                                            3 7 min stay varies

                                                                            • 3 bedrooms
                                                                            • sleeps 7
                                                                            • min stay varies
                                                                            • Child Friendly
                                                                            • Car not necessary
                                                                            • Air conditioning

                                                                            Price per night from

                                                                            $328

                                                                            Price per night from

                                                                            $328

                                                                            Distance approx 17.84 km from Penn Yan

                                                                              24

                                                                              Luxury Sheldrake Farm House on Cayuga Lake Wine Trail, Finger Lakes

                                                                              Finger Lakes / Ovid

                                                                              Ovid house

                                                                              4 8 3 nights min

                                                                              • 4 bedrooms
                                                                              • sleeps 8
                                                                              • 3 nights min
                                                                              • Child Friendly
                                                                              • Air conditioning
                                                                              • Private garden

                                                                              Price per night from

                                                                              $630

                                                                              Price per night from

                                                                              $630