Updating...

More filters (1)

Air conditioning
Wireless Internet
Swimming pool
Private pool

Heated pool
Private indoor pool
Washing machine
Jacuzzi or hot tub
Garden
Internet access
DVD player
Fireplace
Private tennis court
Cot available
Sauna
High chair
Sea view
Safe
Dishwasher
Satellite TV
Children's pool
Table tennis
Games room
Pool or snooker table
Fax machine
Private outdoor pool (heated)
Clothes dryer
Private outdoor pool (unheated)
Shared indoor pool
Shared outdoor pool (unheated)
Shared outdoor pool (heated)
Cribs
Ceiling Fans
Video player
Bicycles available
Boat available
Hair dryer
Gym
Telephone
Solarium or roof terrace
TV
Central heating
Stereo system
Kettle
Toaster
Iron
Stove
Staffed property
Fridge
Freezer
Microwave
Linen provided
Towels provided
Climbing frame
Swing set or jungle gym
Trampoline
Private fishing lake or river
Housekeeping Included

See all

Less

Pets
Pets allowed
Parking
Car not required

Children under 5
Smoking allowed
Non-Smoking property
Smoking - Ask
Elevator access
Wheelchair adapted
Wheelchair accessible
Secure parking

See all

Less

Beach or lakeside relaxation
City breaks
Skiing – property near ski resort
Walking trips

Tennis in town
Nightlife
Water sports
Horse riding
Fishing
Cycling trips
Golf course on site or within 15 min walk
Mountain Views
Beach or lakeside relaxation
Golf within 30mins drive
Lakefront
Waterfront

See all

Less

119 Houses

Sort by:

Waterfront Charmer on idyllic Shelter Island

Shelter Island house

3 bedrooms
3 bathrooms

sleeps 8

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$1,066

Great rentals within 20 miles that match your search

Beach House on Private Treasure Island Drive

Amagansett house

4 bedrooms
3 bathrooms

sleeps 8

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$1,688

East Hampton/Sag Harbor Village Fringe

Sag Harbor house

6 bedrooms
7 bathrooms

sleeps 12

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$3,442

ROMANTIC LUXURY RETREAT WITH POOL & WATER VIEWS, 1 MILE FROM SAG HARBOR VILLAGE

Sag Harbor house

3 bedrooms
2 bathrooms

sleeps 6

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$987

Serene and peaceful beach getaway!

Hampton Bays house

2 bedrooms
2 bathrooms

sleeps 6

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$746

Vacation home in Artistic / Historic area of East Hampton, NY

Springs house

4 bedrooms
4 bathrooms

sleeps 8

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$1,530

Amagansett w/pool last two weeks of August

Amagansett house

3 bedrooms
2 bathrooms

sleeps 7

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$1,606

East Hampton Charming Cottage South Of the Highway Near Ocean/ Further Lane

East Hampton house

3 bedrooms
4 bathrooms

sleeps 8

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$1,922

Seahaven Resort Motel Unit 1

Southampton hotel apartment

1 bedroom
1 bathroom

sleeps 4

Responds fast! avg. 4 minutes

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$229

Seahaven Resort Motel Unit 3

Southampton hotel apartment

1 bedroom
1 bathroom

sleeps 2

Responds fast! avg. 4 minutes

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$240

Seahaven Resort Motel Unit 5

Southampton hotel apartment

1 bedroom
1 bathroom

sleeps 4

Responds fast! avg. 4 minutes

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$240

Seahaven Resort Motel Unit 6

Southampton hotel apartment

1 bedroom
1 bathroom

sleeps 2

Responds fast! avg. 4 minutes

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$229

Seahaven Resort Motel Unit 2

Southampton hotel apartment

1 bedroom
1 bathroom

sleeps 4

Responds fast! avg. 4 minutes

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$240

Seahaven Resort Motel Unit 8

Southampton hotel apartment

1 bedroom
1 bathroom

sleeps 2

Responds fast! avg. 4 minutes

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$229

Seahaven Resort Motel Unit 12

Southampton hotel apartment

1 bedroom
1 bathroom

sleeps 4

Responds fast! avg. 4 minutes

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$240

Seahaven Resort Motel Unit 11

Southampton hotel apartment

1 bedroom
1 bathroom

sleeps 4

Responds fast! avg. 4 minutes

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$240

Seahaven Resort Motel Unit 14

Southampton hotel apartment

1 bedroom
1 bathroom

sleeps 4

Responds fast! avg. 4 minutes

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$240

Seahaven Resort Motel Unit 4

Southampton hotel apartment

1 bedroom
1 bathroom

sleeps 4

Responds fast! avg. 4 minutes

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$240

Seahaven Resort Motel Unit 7

Southampton hotel apartment

1 bedroom
1 bathroom

sleeps 4

Responds fast! avg. 4 minutes

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$206

Seahaven Resort Motel Unit 16

Southampton hotel apartment

1 bedroom
1 bathroom

sleeps 1

Responds fast! avg. 4 minutes

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$240

Seahaven Resort Motel Unit 10

Southampton hotel apartment

1 bedroom
1 bathroom

sleeps 4

Responds fast! avg. 4 minutes

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$263

Seahaven Resort Motel Unit 15

Southampton hotel apartment

1 bedroom
1 bathroom

sleeps 2

Responds fast! avg. 4 minutes

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$343

Seahaven Resort Motel Unit 9

Southampton hotel apartment

1 bedroom
1 bathroom

sleeps 2

Responds fast! avg. 4 minutes

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$240

Seahaven Resort Motel Unit 13

Southampton hotel apartment

1 bedroom
1 bathroom

sleeps 4

Responds fast! avg. 4 minutes

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$240

Seahaven Resort Motel Unit 17

Southampton hotel apartment

1 bedroom
1 bathroom

sleeps 2

Responds fast! avg. 4 minutes

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$229

Relaxed Village Farmhouse

Greenport house

4 bedrooms
3 bathrooms

sleeps 8

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$803

"This must be the place"

Greenport house

3 bedrooms
2 bathrooms

sleeps 6

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$529

Village traditional on a quiet cul de sac

Sag Harbor house

4 bedrooms
4 bathrooms

sleeps 8

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$1,278

Family Vacation Home, heated pool

Amagansett house

3 bedrooms
2 bathrooms

sleeps 6

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$1,257

Charming cottage in the heart of East Hampton village

East Hampton house

2 bedrooms
2 bathrooms

sleeps 4

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$382

Steps to beach 4bd 2 bth Sleeps 13

Clinton house

3 bedrooms
2 bathrooms

sleeps 13

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$345

Summer Vacation House

Hampton Bays house

4 bedrooms
2 bathrooms

sleeps 8

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$382

Village Fringe Ranch

Water Mill house

3 bedrooms
3 bathrooms

sleeps 8

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$574

Direct beachfront pristine home w/Views like a cruise ship for great vacation

Niantic house

2 bedrooms
3 bathrooms

sleeps 7

Responds fast! avg. 14 minutes

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$689

Direct oceanfront pristine home, Niantic Bay, sunrises, private beach,retreat

Niantic house

2 bedrooms
3 bathrooms

sleeps 6

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$574

4BR Waterfront + Dock Family Retreat in Southampton

Southampton house

4 bedrooms
2 bathrooms

sleeps 9

Responds fast! avg. 1 hour 29 minutes

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$1,033

Cozy Cottage with private beach access

South Jamesport house

2 bedrooms
1 bathroom

sleeps 4

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$345

Hamptons Getaway on the water with gorgeous sunsets

East Hampton house

2 bedrooms
2 bathrooms

sleeps 4

Match: Air conditioning

All filters match

Price per night from

$775

Viewing 38 of 119
rentals in Shelter Island

Also consider

Southampton 56 properties
East Hampton 21 properties
Montauk 12 properties
Sag Harbor 11 properties
Amagansett 8 properties
Westhampton Beach 8 properties
Hamptons 137 properties
North Fork 28 properties
Wading River 20 properties
Fire Island 11 properties
Baiting Hollow 7 properties
Long Island 254 properties
Catskill Region 238 properties
Lake Placid 50 properties
Chautauqua County 31 properties
Cattaraugus County 27 properties
Lake George 24 properties
Westchester County 17 properties
Otsego County 15 properties
Wilmington 15 properties
St. Lawrence County 12 properties
Hartwick 11 properties
Severance 10 properties
Albany 10 properties
Fort Plain 9 properties
Olcott 9 properties
Erie County 9 properties
Bolton Landing 8 properties
Hudson 6 properties
Old Forge 6 properties
Hillsdale 5 properties
Wells 5 properties

Shelter Island Rentals

Per night

119 Houses

Viewing 38 of 119rentals in Shelter Island

Also consider

Viewing 38 of 119
rentals in Shelter Island