Eagle Bay Rentals

Close

Enter dates for more accurate prices

Payment Protection
Your payment for this rental is protected when you pay through FlipKey. Learn more

23 Houses

(1) Excellent 

16

Adirondack Luxury Getaway

New York / Eagle Bay

Eagle Bay house

3 8 2 nights min

  • 3 bedrooms
  • sleeps 8
  • 2 nights min
  • Child Friendly
  • Ask about pets
  • Private garden

Price per night from

$250

Price per night from

$250

Great rentals within 20 miles that match your search

Distance approx 3.2 km from Eagle Bay Show on Map

(1) Excellent 

7

Birches Cottage one of Four Seasons Cottages

New York / Old Forge

Old Forge house

2 4 2 nights min

  • 2 bedrooms
  • sleeps 4
  • 2 nights min
  • Child Friendly

Price per night from

$126

Price per night from

$126

Distance approx 2.9 km from Eagle Bay Show on Map

(5) Excellent 

23

Adirondacks 3 bdrm lakefront camp with sand beach

New York / Inlet

Inlet log cabin

3 7 7 nights min

  • 3 bedrooms
  • sleeps 7
  • 7 nights min
  • Beach / lakeside relaxation
  • Nearest beach 0 mi
  • Child Friendly

Price per night from

$257

Price per night from

$257

Distance approx 5.84 km from Eagle Bay Show on Map

(12) Excellent 

9

Adirondack Vacation Cabin

New York / Old Forge

Old Forge log cabin

2 6 min stay varies

  • 2 bedrooms
  • sleeps 6
  • min stay varies
  • Nearest beach 2 mi
  • Child Friendly
  • Air conditioning

Price per night from

$114

Price per night from

$114

Distance approx 9.39 km from Eagle Bay

21

The Lodge on Main

New York / Old Forge

Old Forge lodge

4 12 3 nights min

  • 4 bedrooms
  • sleeps 12
  • 3 nights min
  • Child Friendly
  • Air conditioning

Price per night from

$425

Price per night from

$425

Distance approx 3.2 km from Eagle Bay Show on Map

(3) Excellent 

13

Mountain View Cottage part of Four Seasons Cottages on 4th Lake Old Forge NY

New York / Old Forge

Old Forge house

4 10 2 nights min

  • 4 bedrooms
  • sleeps 10
  • 2 nights min
  • Nearest beach 0 mi
  • Child Friendly

Price per night from

$200

Price per night from

$200

Distance approx 8.3 km from Eagle Bay Show on Map

20

Upscale Waterfront Villa With Best Location (LedgeRock Guest House)

New York / Old Forge

Old Forge villa

2 4 2 nights min

  • 2 bedrooms
  • sleeps 4
  • 2 nights min
  • Nearest beach 0.4 mi
  • Child Friendly

Price per night from

$403

Responds fast!
avg. 38 minutes

Price per night from

$403

Distance approx 3.2 km from Eagle Bay Show on Map

(2) Very Good 

5

Roaring Brook Cottage Four Seasons Cottages Old Forge NY

New York / Old Forge

Old Forge cottage

4 10 2 nights min

  • 4 bedrooms
  • sleeps 10
  • 2 nights min
  • Beach / lakeside relaxation
  • Nearest beach 0 mi
  • Child Friendly

Price per night from

$191

Price per night from

$191

Distance approx 3.2 km from Eagle Bay Show on Map

(4) Very Good 

22

Four Seasons Lodge on 4th Lake Old Forge NY

New York / Old Forge

Old Forge house

7 16 3 nights min

  • 7 bedrooms
  • sleeps 16
  • 3 nights min
  • Beach / lakeside relaxation
  • Child Friendly
  • Private garden

Price per night from

$500

Price per night from

$500

Distance approx 18.94 km from Eagle Bay

(16) Very Good 

15

Otter Lake Cottage- 10 Miles south of Old Forge

New York / Forestport

Forestport cottage

3 6 1 night min

  • 3 bedrooms
  • sleeps 6
  • 1 night min
  • Nearest beach 16 mi
  • Child Friendly
  • Private garden
“Cozy and convenient!” This is a great rustic cabin with all the amenities. Close to Old Forge but far enough away to get the woodsy feel of the Adirondacks. Luanne and Andy were accommodating and helpful. We will definitely stay here again!
…see more

Price per night from

$98

Responds fast!
avg. 1 hour 7 minutes

Price per night from

$98

Distance approx 9.93 km from Eagle Bay

(2) Very Good 

17

3 bedroom Adirondack Camp/House

New York / Old Forge

Old Forge house

3 10 2 nights min

  • 3 bedrooms
  • sleeps 10
  • 2 nights min
  • Nearest beach 2 mi
  • Child Friendly
  • Private garden

Price per night from

$252

Responds fast!
avg. 3 hours 35 minutes

Price per night from

$252

Distance approx 9.87 km from Eagle Bay

(5) Excellent 

28

Moon Over Moose Luxury Waterfront Log Home, Adirondack Mountains, Old Forge, NY

New York / Old Forge

Old Forge log cabin

5 10 min stay varies

  • 5 bedrooms
  • sleeps 10
  • min stay varies
  • Beach / lakeside relaxation
  • Nearest beach 3 mi
  • Child Friendly

Price per night from

$375

Responds fast!
avg. 53 minutes

Price per night from

$375

Distance approx 7.41 km from Eagle Bay Show on Map

(4) Excellent 

58

SANDY BEACH ACCESS! Desired Old Forge Location. Quiet Area, Deck, Wash/Dryer! CW

New York / Old Forge

Old Forge house

2 6 min stay varies

  • 2 bedrooms
  • sleeps 6
  • min stay varies
  • Beach / lakeside relaxation
  • Nearest beach 2 mi
  • Child Friendly
“Great family getaway” This was the perfect place with children. Toys, games, room to play inside and outside. We could not have picked a better location. The cabin was extremely clean and very well taken care of. It's very close to everything in old f
…see more

Price per night from

$179

Responds fast!
avg. 1 hour 28 minutes

Price per night from

$179

Distance approx 8.3 km from Eagle Bay Show on Map

(1) Excellent 

34

Modern Waterfront Vacation Rental with Best Location (Ledgerock)

New York / Old Forge

Old Forge villa

3 6 5 nights min

  • 3 bedrooms
  • sleeps 6
  • 5 nights min
  • Nearest beach 0.4 mi
  • Child Friendly

Price per night from

$604

Responds fast!
avg. 38 minutes

Price per night from

$604

Distance approx 4.75 km from Eagle Bay Show on Map

24

Lakefront Old Forge Home w/Private Boat Ramp+Beach

New York / Old Forge

Old Forge house

7 14 min stay varies

  • 7 bedrooms
  • sleeps 14
  • min stay varies
  • Child Friendly

Price per night from

$435

Responds fast!
avg. 8 minutes

Price per night from

$435

Distance approx 7.36 km from Eagle Bay Show on Map

(2) Very Good 

32

3 min to Downtown Old Forge! Sandy Beach Access. Ideal Location w/Dead-End. BR

New York / Old Forge

Old Forge house

3 10 min stay varies

  • 3 bedrooms
  • sleeps 10
  • min stay varies
  • Child Friendly
  • Air conditioning

Price per night from

$217

Responds fast!
avg. 1 hour 28 minutes

Price per night from

$217

Distance approx 9.79 km from Eagle Bay

28

Cozy Old Forge Home w/2 Porches, Fire Pit, Hot Tub

New York / Thendara

Thendara house

3 8 min stay varies

  • 3 bedrooms
  • sleeps 8
  • min stay varies
  • Ski
  • Child Friendly

Price per night from

$255

Responds fast!
avg. 10 minutes

Price per night from

$255

Distance approx 8.4 km from Eagle Bay Show on Map

(1)  

20

Camp Enchantment

New York / Old Forge

Old Forge house

3 8 7 nights min

  • 3 bedrooms
  • sleeps 8
  • 7 nights min
  • Child Friendly
  • Private garden

Price per night from

$250

Price per night from

$250

Distance approx 1.63 km from Eagle Bay Show on Map

24

NEW! Cozy Loft-Style Apartment on Inlet Harbor!

New York / Inlet

Inlet apartment

3 8 min stay varies

  • 3 bedrooms
  • sleeps 8
  • min stay varies
  • Child Friendly

Price per night from

$186

Responds fast!
avg. 8 minutes

Price per night from

$186

Distance approx 7.44 km from Eagle Bay Show on Map

16

Adirondack 6BR/4B Waterfront, Tennis Court, Large Lot, Sand VB, Dock, Boat House

New York / Old Forge

Old Forge house

6 16 3 nights min

  • 6 bedrooms
  • sleeps 16
  • 3 nights min
  • Beach / lakeside relaxation
  • Child Friendly

Price per night from

$500

Price per night from

$500

Distance approx 4.71 km from Eagle Bay Show on Map

(1)  

34

Shangri-La

New York / Old Forge

Old Forge villa

7 14 3 nights min

  • 7 bedrooms
  • sleeps 14
  • 3 nights min
  • Beach / lakeside relaxation
  • Child Friendly
  • Car not necessary

Price per night from

$600

Responds fast!
avg. 33 minutes

Price per night from

$600

Distance approx 8.49 km from Eagle Bay

(1) Very Good 

71

12 BR 12 Bath Large Adirondack Family Rental

New York / Old Forge

Old Forge log cabin

12 24 min stay varies

  • 12 bedrooms
  • sleeps 24
  • min stay varies
  • Beach / lakeside relaxation
  • Child Friendly

Price per night from

$1,200

Price per night from

$1,200

Distance approx 18.98 km from Eagle Bay

33

Waterfront Vacation Rental on Otter Lake Located 15 Minutes South of Old Forge

New York / Forestport

Forestport house

3 8 3 nights min

  • 3 bedrooms
  • sleeps 8
  • 3 nights min
  • Beach / lakeside relaxation
  • Child Friendly

Price per night from

$275

Price per night from

$275